Reviews
What User likes about Theresa’s South:
I chose to dine at Theresa South on multiple occasions because they have never let me down. Service is outstanding, menu has something for everyone, and food of course is amazing. I do not even have to look at the menu, I get the Tune entree, outstanding View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Theresa’s South:
menu choices specials plentifully varied. service excellent. burrata special; spinat salat tasty. calamari beautiful crisp but bland . tagitele mushroom pasta alwys are a favorite prices that they are. whole restaurant with taking out the lighting needs a re-do. outdated wall flower arrangements- drag her down! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Almost no one there The service was good and all the food was delicious from the appetizer to the dessert. We will go back again
Everything was great...servers were friendly, service was quick, and food was great...definitely coming back
The food at Theresa's is remarkably good; start with the signature eggplant pancake, topped with lots of delicious mozzarella and pesto, then proceed to any of...
read moreThe food was okay, but wasn't better than most in that category. Although the server was very nice, they need to train their staff a little better. Dirty plates...
read moreFirst time at the Theresa's. Food was very good. Nice atmosphere
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreTheresa's South offers a menu with abundant and varied choices, delicious food, and excellent service. Dishes like the eggplant pancake and penne broccoli rabe with sausage are highlights. However, some diners found issues with the portion sizes and service, feeling rushed to order. Others were impressed by the Valentine's Day prix fixe menu, with tender filet mignon and delicious desserts. Despite some minor shortcomings with specific dishes, Theresa's South remains a favorite spot for many return patrons, with some making reservations in advance to secure a table. Overall, this restaurant promises a satisfying dining experience with standout dishes and cozy ambiance.
Lovely restaurant in Bay Head. Great food, great ambiance and efficient service. We are excited to host our rehearsal dinner here in May! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atm...
read moreFantastic menu, delicious food and great service. Party of 4 and everyone was incredibly happy with our dinners. Great Caesar salad! Short ribs, paoardelle, rig...
read moreOrdered snapper which was dry and very overcooked, filet was good, pasta dishes were good but dissappointed in the small portion of pasta on the plates. They al...
read moreWe had dinner with friends at Theresa's South last night. We were seated quickly and the first thing we noticed was that we could hear each other! Theresa's Sou...
read moreWas blown away by the incredible Italian food here. I tried the Linguini Fra Diavolo. The pasta was homemade and the seafood was so fresh!!! Lia was my server....
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreGreat food, great service and great value always consistently good.
Tables inside are on top of each other. Food was good service was good. It was loud and you were less then 6 inches from table next to you . Waiter reached over...
read moreWe go to Theresa's South at least once a month and we go for the Tuna sushi rare. It is fabulous. This week we started with sharing the stuffed pepper appetizer...
read moreFood was good. We felt very rushed and were out in an hour. Had the grilled peach salad and peaches were hard. Tuna was great, but the presentation left a bit t...
read moreThe prices were high and the portions of the food were small. The service was just adequate. Probably would not return. There are several other restaurants in t...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreMy party of 4 thoroughly enjoyed our visit to Theresa's. Benjamin was great at taking care of us along with the other servers. We started with the fried calamar...
read moreNot your average NJ BYOB Italian joint. Theresa's is fantastic, every dish I have tried has been excellent. Ambiance and service are just as great as the food!...
read moreWhat really put Theresa's over the top for me was their service. The waiters are young but so well trained, very friendly and respectful. The food came at the p...
read moreFirst visit to Theresa's South. It's BYOB and we ran over to Burke's to pick up some wine. Ambiance and service it was Friday night and not very busy. We were s...
read moreThis is our second time here and another fantastic dining experience. From start to finish the service was excellent. I love seafood and decided to try the Blac...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreNot a fan of broccoli rabe. Too bitter. Would prefer some haricot verts as a side vegetable
The Sweet Potato Gnocchi with Braised Short Rib was priced at $33.00 and only contained about four small bite-sized pieces of short rib. It is disappointing tha...
read moreThe food at this restaurant is consistently excellent. We would definitely order dessert if they offered it.
The food was incredibly tasty!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more