Rye - Appleton

Foods good they always have oysters so that's a huge plus. Went a couple weeks ago and the bartender was terrible. Bar was not full dinning room was which is sm... read more Foods good they always have oysters so that's a huge plus. Went a couple weeks ago and the bartender was terrible. Bar was not full dinning room was which is small and I showed up with a party of 5 waited 15 min before the bartender said he was to slammed to serve us lol. That guy is definitely not cut out for the industry. Went to a different restaurant and had great food perfect service and they were also slammed Food: 4

Came here for NYE and everything was 10/10. I ordered the scallops (to die for) and my boyfriend ordered the steak. We finished the meal with the vanilla crème... read more Came here for NYE and everything was 10/10. I ordered the scallops (to die for) and my boyfriend ordered the steak. We finished the meal with the vanilla crème brûlée. The portions were decent, service was great and the atmosphere is always amazing. I will always be happy to return to Rye. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

First date spot! Immediately felt welcomed and seen by waitstaff; waiter was fun and hilarious; food was excellent in every way. Environment was homey, comforta... read more First date spot! Immediately felt welcomed and seen by waitstaff; waiter was fun and hilarious; food was excellent in every way. Environment was homey, comfortable, and relaxing. Very enjoyable experience! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Never had a bad meal here but staff and atmosphere need real help. Wednesday 7/20/2022 6pm reservations. Promptly greeted and seated.Too dark to read the menu.... read more Never had a bad meal here but staff and atmosphere need real help. Wednesday 7/20/2022 6pm reservations. Promptly greeted and seated.Too dark to read the menu. (Three tables near us also used the flashlight on their phone)To make matters worse we hadone person at our table facing the front of the restaurant and the bright light was blinding him. No shade on the window todraw down. Waiter did not care. Music is not fine dining and too loud. (50’s Hound Dog Elvis, and Animal House Shout we’rethe first two songs and it continued) This is advertised as a fine dining establishment based on food, drinks and prices,unfortunately some people think shorts and a T shirt are acceptable anywhere. Wish this place (and others) had a dress code. We like to dress up and celebrate when we go out for an occasion. This isn’t a pancake house which I also love and wearshorts and a T shirt to when I go but Rye is labeled as fine dining. Atmosphere was nice upon entry (6pm weeknight) but by7:25pm the conversations were so noisy it was way too much. Food: Stuffed Date small plate, quantity 4 exactly as described.Marinara spiced sauce under the dates also very tasty. Whiskey Shrimp small plate had a wonderful garlic herb tomato sauce addictive sopped it up with the bread! Pork chops with carrots tender and delicious! Salmon perfectly cooked and awesomesauce. Brussels sprouts were cook thru and charred on the outside. Burger great! Hint of heat with the jalapeños but thejerk sauce makes it fabulous. Pink as ordered. Ravioli with the arugula on the side. More al dente then I like but delicioussauce and filling. Waiter Shane knew the menu very well. He initially was attentive but once entrees were served and tablesstarted filling we were forgotten. He walked by and asked if everything was ok but was past the table before we could respondand looked over his shoulder as one of us said “tastes good!” Also Shane never came back for more drinks and our empty bar

Amazing atmosphere. Great service. Phenomenal food. Incredible drinks. Here’s what we had House Malbec and Blackberry Lavender Martini along with Sautéed Whisky... read more Amazing atmosphere. Great service. Phenomenal food. Incredible drinks. Here’s what we had House Malbec and Blackberry Lavender Martini along with Sautéed Whisky Bacon Shrimp to start. Then the Filet Mignon and Pan Seared Scallops. CrèmeBrûlée for dessert topped it off perfectly. If we could have, we would have had seconds of everything it was so beyonddelicious. We will be back. Keep up the fantastic menu!!