Restaurants in Muttontown

1611 with menu

Main Categories

Amenities

Ratings

Search Range

The top 20 restaurants from Muttontown sorted by reviews.

★ 4.2 / 5 (13533 reviews)
Steak Sushi Seafood Meat Cheese

Rothmann's Steakhouse

Menu Reviews

Northern Boulevard 6319, 11732-1629 EAST NORWICH, US

Rothmann's, a longstanding steakhouse in America, falls short when it comes to quality service and overpriced menu items, according to several patrons...

Fireplace, Outdoor dining, Reservation, Cocktails
★ 4.4 / 5 (6442 reviews)
#4 Pizza in OYSTER BAY Italian Salads

Mario's Pizza

Menu Reviews

Pine Hollow Road 253, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US

At this Long Island pizzeria, diners encounter a mixed bag of experiences. While many rave about the extensive selection of pizza slices, including st...

Takeout, Wifi, Curbside pickup, Beer
★ 4.5 / 5 (1793 reviews)
French Bar-lounge Delivery Services

Hunter The

Menu Reviews

Oyster Bay Road 1053, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US

Hunter Restaurant continues to impress diners with its exquisite cuisine and welcoming atmosphere. Guests consistently rave about the attentive servic...

Takeout, Parking area, Staff wear masks, Great cocktails
★ 4.1 / 5 (504 reviews)
Italian Pizza Chocolate Ice Cream

La Pizzetta

Menu Reviews

Oyster Bay Road 1008, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US

#### Restaurant Review: A Tale of Two Experiences Located on the North Shore, this restaurant offers an enchanting menu with a mix of excellent dishe...

Hard liquor, High chairs, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Dinner
★ 3.7 / 5 (542 reviews)
Wraps Sandwiches Smoothies Catering

Messina Market

Menu Reviews

Northern Boulevard 6255, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US

**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag Experience** Despite a previously favorable reputation, recent visits to this establishment have revealed significan...
★ 4.6 / 5 (2662 reviews)
Mediterranean Delivery Services Greek

Greek Cove

Menu

Oyster Bay Road 1003, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US
★ 4.2 / 5 (199 reviews)
Pizza American North American

Red Tomato Pizza

Menu Reviews

Northern Boulevard 6245, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US

Delivery, Families with children, Dinner, Wheelchair accessible seating
★ 2.4 / 5 (516 reviews)
#35 Pizza in OYSTER BAY

Baskin-robbins

Menu Reviews

Pine Hollow Road 159, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US

**Restaurant Review: A Disappointing Experience** Despite its convenient location, this restaurant has become infamous for incredibly poor service an...
★ 4.4 / 5 (296 reviews)
#1 Pizza in OYSTER BAY

Mama Mia’s Pizza Pasta (formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay)

Menu Reviews

342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, USA, OYSTER BAY, United States

"The owner is rude and disrespectful to patrons and staff."

Delivery, Takeout, Parking area, Wifi
★ 3.1 / 5 (10 reviews)
Cafe Burgers Coffee Tea Cheese

Magnolia Cafe

Menu Reviews

1395 Planting Fields Rd, Oyster Bay, USA, Village of Upper Brookville, United States

Outdoor Seating, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Cash only

"Cute little cafe. Seating outside, social distancing in place."
★ 4.4 / 5 (5 reviews)
#3 Seafood in OYSTER BAY Steak

J. Michaels Tuscan Steakhouse

Menu

Mill River Road 160, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US

"The ramen bowls were enjoyable, but the sushi was disappointing. It didn't appear very fresh and was somewhat overpriced."
★ 4.8 / 5 (2024 reviews)
Greek Falafel Meat Chicken Salad

Greek Cove East Norwich

Menu Reviews

Oyster Bay Road 1011, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US

A neighborhood Mediterranean and bagel spot praised for fresh bagels, bacon‑egg‑cheese sandwiches, rice bowls, gyros, falafel and baklava at wallet‑fr...

Dinner, Mask required, Wheelchair accessible restroom, Good for groups
★ 3.3 / 5 (4215 reviews)
#34 Pizza in OYSTER BAY Fast Food

McDonald's

Reviews

Pine Hollow Road 245, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US

The McDonald's location in question has received mixed reviews, with many customers expressing frustration over various aspects of their experience. C...
★ 4.7 / 5 (1524 reviews)
#6 Pizza in OYSTER BAY

Pietro's Brick Oven Pizza

Menu Reviews

Lexington Avenue 342, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US
★ 4.3 / 5 (1002 reviews)
#5 Seafood in OYSTER BAY

Coach Grill Tavern

Menu Reviews

Pine Hollow Road 22, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US

Nestled in the heart of Oyster Bay, this restaurant captivates with its exceptional crabcake appetizer and thoughtfully crafted entrees. Diners rave a...

Outdoor Seating, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Parking area
★ 4.3 / 5 (176 reviews)
Bakeries Bakery Grocery

Dortoni

Reviews

6247 Northern Blvd, East Norwich, New York, USA, 11732, EAST NORWICH, United States

D'Ortoni Bakery, once celebrated for its exceptional offerings, now faces scrutiny as patrons express concerns over declining quality, particularly th...
★ 4.5 / 5 (282 reviews)
Italian Brunch Lunch Pizzeria Pizza

Leone Trattoria Pizzeria

Menu Reviews

1027 Oyster Bay Rd, East Norwich I-11732-1003, United States, EAST NORWICH

This family-owned Italian pizzeria in the East Norwich/Oyster Bay area serves NYC-quality pizza and classic Italian dishes—standout arancini, bruschet...

Delivery, Appetizers (arancini, bruschetta), Pizza, Takeout service
★ 3.0 / 5 (1084 reviews)
Coffee Coffee Donuts Coffee & Tea

Dunkin'

Menu Reviews

Pine Hollow Road 159, 11771 OYSTER BAY, US

Nestled in Oyster Bay, this Dunkin' wins praise for fresh coffee, clean premises and honest, often friendly staff, with reliable donuts and munchkins...

Accepts Credit Cards, Donuts, Munchkins, Takeout
★ 3.0 / 5 (1 reviews)
American Pizza

Saggio Pizza Pasta Cafe

Menu

Oyster Bay Road 1029, 11732 EAST NORWICH, US
★ 4.3 / 5 (5 reviews)
#9 Pizza in OYSTER BAY

Ralph's Famous Italian Ice

Menu

117 Pine Hollow Rd, OYSTER BAY, United States

Nestled among neighborhood favorites, this ice cream spot earns praise for inventive flavors, spotless presentation and friendly, allergy-aware servic...

Delivery, Many flavors, Pints/to-go, Allergy accommodation

1611 restaurants from Muttontown (United States).