Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Red Tomato Pizza:
Everything was fine until a server approached us while we were eating dinner and asked us to move to another table because they needed ours for a party of eight. We ended up not finishing our meal. They offered us complimentary dessert, but I suggested that they let us keep our table instead. We likely won't be returning, as I found the whole situation to be quite ridiculous. Why should we have to get up and move our... View all feedback.
Was eaten pizza and always wanted to try this place and boy not disappointed. The ambience, friendly staff and cleanliness were more than expected. The dough was so fluffy and perfectly baked. Our waitress was so sweet and patient, especially with us with 3 children. Everything was made fresh and I will definitely come back and make this part of my weekly pizza Fridays. Can wait to try more stuff on the menu.
The worst thing about this place is that. THE BREAD IS SO GOOD I CANT STOP EATING IT!!! I order pizza from here often, but even the sandwiches and salads are good enough to literally eat every day. I?ve never tasted dough like theirs. I love the staff, Irene is always there and so sweet and welcoming. The space is clean and the decor is awesome. #selfienation Definitely recommend!
Went here for the first time yesterday for dinner. The food and service was absolutely phenomenal. Legitimately the best brick oven pizza restaurant around, with a variety of options! The tartufo pizza is by far my absolute favorite!
So yummy! Passed by this place on Northern millions of times and finally decided to go in. Glad we did...super good food and lovely staff. Gorgeous decor and very comfortable seating too!
Found this gem after a hike at Muttontown Preserve. Had an excellent wood fired margarita pizza with cauliflower crust and the tomato basil soup. The setting is more upscale than a pizzeria and the prices reflect it, but worth a little extra. Will go back to try more of the extensive menu items.
Full Menu
Cocktail
Antipasti
Snacks
Dessert
Baked
Vegetarian
More information
QR-code link to the menu
