Reviews
What Gee P doesn't like about Toasty Sandwich Shop:
Spent over $40 bucks on two sandwiches and an iced coffee. Then waited 30 minutes for the food. Iced Carmel latte was a waste of money. Straight Carmel syrup in 1/4 of the cup. Pastrami melt never ever again, second half tasted like hot dog. I felt fooled by the chopped cheeese pictures. It was bland like they didn’t even put salt. I tried finishing my second half, cause again… over $40 bucks… two bites into the seco... View all feedback. What Manuel Mansfield likes about Toasty Sandwich Shop:
I love this place, they have the best sandwiches, very quick service and again awesome sandwiches. The atmosphere is very warm and inviting, I love going there getting sandwiches and have a chat with my friends View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Please, please invest into stickers for your drinks on Uber Eats because my drink spilled in his car on his way to deliver my food. I only had half my coffee co...
read moreWhat’s the point of ordering ahead if you have to wait 30 minutes after they tell u food it ready. Waist of time
I love this place. My go too for anytime of the day, and the Ice coffees are delicious.
Great food and excellent service. The French toast sandwhich and chopped cheese are both amazing!!!
Nice high quality deli. Lots of good sandwiches. The Lady Lover is delicious.
MAGIC CHOPPED CHEESE was way too salty for me but the ORIGINAL FRENCH FRIES and TROPICAL SUN were good
You have a fantastic place! Everything is consistently great! Keep up the excellent work! Thank you!
You have to try the FIRE WRAP! The atmosphere of the place is really relaxed. Great job overall!
This is by far the best sandwich shop in the area. I've been waiting for a place like this in YONKERS for ages. I ordered a custom sandwich, and they completely...
read moreMelted Cheese Fries are on point