Three Fingered Jack's - Winthrop
Three Fingered Jack's
Description
Three Finger Jack's offers a mixed dining experience in Winthrop, where the ambiance reflects its western heritage. While some guests rave about flavorful dishes like the chicken Caesar salad wrap and the Swiss and mushroom burger, others criticize the inconsistent food quality and slow service, citing staff being overwhelmed during busy times. The atmosphere remains lively, particularly during local events, though patrons have noted a lack of staff and menu items. Despite some shortcomings, many appreciate the quirky vibe and unique menu offerings, making it a potential stop for those exploring the area.
Images
Reservation request for Three Fingered Jack's
Feedback
Nice looking place from the outside. Closed until Thursday.
I was very underwhelmed by this place. If it was just about the service I would say one star. Our waiter had a very bad attitude and it was obvious he did not want to be there. I asked for drink suggestions because I like sweet drinks and generally allow the bartender to make something for me. He refused to speak to the bartender and said he had to have a drink name to put in his machine. At one point he said I 'm not a bartender . The bartenders, however, were awesome! Other than that, the food was ok. Nothing special but ok. Food: 3 Service: 1
I was there New Year's Eve to ring in 2025. It was one of the best nights out I've ever had. Top 5 for sure and I'm old! The woman running the show just exuded so much love. She sincerely wanted everyone to just be happy and that sentiment is rare. I don't know her name but she taught me something that night; the local Winthrop people are good and kind, especially at the Three Finger. There is hope at The Three! [Plus, thanks to my girl who insisted we go! Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5
Friendly service and very attentive . Especially like the battered shrimp and the hummus plate! Come and enjoy.
Unfortunately the bar staff was not the most welcoming or attentive. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 3 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 3
Menu
Small Plates
Jack's Mac CheeseOur delicious; creamy bowl of traditional mac cheese. Includes applesauce
$7.4All You Can Eat Pizza & Salad Buffet
Specialty Wines3 Finger Jack Cabernet; The Calling Pinot Noir
$24.6Happy Hour Drinks
Wine By The BottleStonecap Chardonnay; Sagelands Pinot Grigio; Canyon Road White Zinfandel; Sagelands Cabernet; Sagelands Riverbed Red
$17.7Salad
House Green SaladChoice of salad dressing Ranch; Balsamic Vinaigrette; Thousand Island; Bleu Cheese; Raspberry Vinaigrette; Honey Mustard. Extra sauces & dressings $0.50) Balsamic vinaigrette; Habanero ketchup; Thousand Island; Chipotle ranch; Ranch dressing; Bleu chees
$5.5Pizzas / Calzones
A perfectly sized single serving + Mozzarella cheese & sauce. Includes applesauce
$7.4Entrées
$9.8
Menu PDF
FAQ
More information
QR-Code for the menu
