The Milk Pail

Reviews

Overall Total Score

3.7 out of 5

Very good | 116 reviews

What User likes about The Milk Pail:
There is a wide variety of items on the menu, though they are a bit on the expensive side. I was hoping for more cheese options, but overall, my meal exceeded my expectations. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

I visited a charming little market and purchased some delicious cheese, soppressa, and barbecued beef.

There is a wide variety of items on the menu, though they are a bit on the expensive side. I was hoping for more cheese options, but overall, my meal exceeded m...

The food is fresh and delicious, but it is slightly pricier than expected.

I had the best pfirsich cake, so delicious soft cookies, and top-off with coffee smoothie.

Been going to the Milk Pail for 20 years. Jennifer knows us as the Gals who come on Sunday of Columbus day weekend. Always have a great time the apples never ev...

Last update : 18.09.2022

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near WATER MILL

Almond Bridgehampton

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Bridgehampton (near WATER MILL), One Ocean RoadNY 11932, Bridgehampton, United States

"Excellent as always, esp the Fat Farmer and the burger."

##6 European in Bridgehamp...

Details

#6 European in Bridgehampton

Bostwick's Chowder House

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: East Hampton (near WATER MILL), 277 Pantigo Road, East Hampton, New York, 11937, United States

"Good attentive service and has a beautiful local atmosphere, but the quality of the food is inconsistent. Came here in April 2022 and had amazing lobs..."

##11 Cafés in East Hampton

Details

#11 Cafés in East Hampton

Greenport Harbor Brewing Co.

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Peconic (near WATER MILL), 42155 Main Rd, Peconic I-11958-1502, United States

"I loved this place for the first time 3-4 years ago. I love it today. The food and beer was amazing. I had the Curry sausage and my wife had the Crab..."

##4 Cafés in Peconic

Details

#4 Cafés in Peconic

North Fork Table & Inn

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Southold (near WATER MILL), North Fork & Shelter Island, 57225 Main Rd, 11971-4750, Southold, United States

"Everything was good, but way overpriced"

#American

Details

American American Desserts Bars

1 North

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Hampton Bays (near WATER MILL), 322 W Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, USA, United States

"Everything about dinner was great Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $100+ Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Bacon Wrapped Local S..."

##15 Seafood in Hampton Ba...

Details

#15 Seafood in Hampton Bays