Stewart's Shop - Wallkill

I'm not typically one to leave reviews, especially negative ones, but I feel compelled to share my experience. This was the fourth time I've encountered the sam... read more I'm not typically one to leave reviews, especially negative ones, but I feel compelled to share my experience. This was the fourth time I've encountered the same rude employee when asking for ice cream. She treats the requests like it's a major inconvenience, as if making the ice cream orders is a hassle for her. Each time I visited, the place wasn't crowded, so I wasn't holding anyone up. Yet, she has rolled her eyes and sighed heavily every time I've dealt with her. The employee’s name is Claire, so you can take that information as you wish.

The staff is always friendly, although the restaurant tends to be understaffed in the evenings. read more The staff is always friendly, although the restaurant tends to be understaffed in the evenings.

Stewart's is fantastic! I've never had a negative experience at any of their locations. The parking lot is clean, although a bit cramped. There are four gas pum... read more Stewart's is fantastic! I've never had a negative experience at any of their locations. The parking lot is clean, although a bit cramped. There are four gas pumps available. The employees are friendly and welcoming. If you have the opportunity, be sure to try the ice cream and ask about the flavor of the week!

This is an average restaurant. The staff is usually friendly, which is nice. However, I don’t appreciate having to pay for a bag to protect my car seat when buy... read more This is an average restaurant. The staff is usually friendly, which is nice. However, I don’t appreciate having to pay for a bag to protect my car seat when buying a half-gallon of ice cream or a gallon of milk. It feels a bit stingy on Stewart’s part, prompting me to visit other stores more frequently. That said, their ice cream is tasty whether you get it served or buy it in a half-gallon. On the plus side, they do offer ethanol-free gas if you opt for the 91 octane, allowing you to purchase better fuel instead of the usual low-quality options.

It's quite frustrating how this busy gas station claims to open at 4:30 AM, yet there's rarely any coffee available when I arrive. Often, I find myself waiting... read more It's quite frustrating how this busy gas station claims to open at 4:30 AM, yet there's rarely any coffee available when I arrive. Often, I find myself waiting and having to ask for creamers. The most irritating part is when I'm stuck waiting to pump gas for 15 minutes because the staff member opening up is in the back getting everything ready. I understand that everyone has an off day, but this happens daily. Since I use non-ethanol fuel, I can't just go elsewhere. When I brought it to Nikki, the opener's attention, she brushed it off and offered no solutions, leaving me to be late for work because she can't seem to get to hers on time!