Domenico's Pizzeria - Wallkill
Domenico's Pizzeria
Description
Domenico’s Pizzeria offers a mixed but notable experience. Many appreciate its friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and creatively topped pizzas like the popular "Crime Scene," alongside fresh-made Garlic Knots. The Sicilian and Buffalo chicken pizzas receive particular praise. Recent improvements include a remodeled counter and expanded staff, enhancing service during busy hours. However, some customers report inconsistent pizza quality, limited menu availability during off-hours, and occasional unfriendly service that detracts from the experience. Despite these issues, Domenico’s remains a beloved local spot known for hearty portions and a welcoming vibe, ideal for casual dining or quick takeout in Plattekill.
Images
Feedback
This is by far the best pizza I’ve come across, and it’s conveniently nearby. I ordered what I call the “Crime Scene” pizza—loaded with mozzarella, meatballs, and generous spoonfuls of ricotta cheese spread all over. Although it looks a bit chaotic, the flavor is incredible. All my friends have started ordering their pizzas the same way because they love it so much. It’s not on the official menu, but definitely ask for it when you order. Also, don’t miss the Garlic Knots—they’re freshly made to order!
Domenico's makes pizza exactly how we like it! From the very first time we tried it, we knew this would be our go-to pizza place. We've been getting pizza almost every week since because we enjoy it so much! It's a wonderful spot with friendly staff.
We're thrilled to have found this spot! The pizza is incredibly tasty, and the wings are outstanding. This has definitely become our new favorite pizzeria!
Menu PDF
FAQ
More information
QR-Code for the menu
