Your Pie - St. Augustine

Your Pie Pizza is some of the best pizza I've ever eaten!My wife and I moved to St Augustine about 6 weeks ago and we've eaten here about 8 times. I always get... read more Your Pie Pizza is some of the best pizza I've ever eaten!My wife and I moved to St Augustine about 6 weeks ago and we've eaten here about 8 times. I always get the pepperoni pizza and some of their amazing Ranch dressing with dill in it and I'm like Scooby Doo after a Scooby snack. My wife switches it up but has been thoroughly satisfied every time.Kim and her crew have done a great job in turning this store around and we can't recommend Your Pie strongly enough. 8 times in 6 weeks says it all folks. It would be more but my wife gets to choose sometimes too lol.Small business is the backbone of the American economy and restaurants are a very tough way to make a living in the very best of times and we all know that the last couple of years have not been the best of times what with Covid lockdowns and all of the restrictions we all had to live under.I applaud Your Pie and every other small business for taking all of the risks. I will never be one to try and sink them because of one bad experience (which happens everywhere I'm sure). Places have bad days occasionally, that is a fact of life, but even then I will almost always give them another chance. If you've had a bad experience I suggest that you give them another chance. It's only the right thing to do for a place that's helping keep America afloat and are still coming out of the Covid junk.Sorry for the rant but when I see bad reviews for such a good place with such amazing food I scratch my head and wonder if those people even went to the place they're writing about, at least in this case I do. Your Pie is great! I hope that you have a chance to try them. If you had a bad experience, give them a chance to make it up to you. We all deserve a little Grace sometimes. And no I'm not afamily member, I'm just a big fan.Thanks Your Pie. I'll be seeing you soon ?Take Care and Happy Eating (and ranting ?)Rick W

The service at this pizza restaurant was excellent. I ordered the 14 inch lineage supreme pizza and it was loaded with plenty of meats and vegetables. The wait... read more The service at this pizza restaurant was excellent. I ordered the 14 inch lineage supreme pizza and it was loaded with plenty of meats and vegetables. The wait time was only about ten minutes from order to completion. The finished product was very tasty and the price was reasonable.

I have always been impressed with the customer service and the food, which is why I choose Your Pie on my busy days between jobs, but today I was suddenly told... read more I have always been impressed with the customer service and the food, which is why I choose Your Pie on my busy days between jobs, but today I was suddenly told that I could no longer place an order over the phone. Even though a young gentleman had answered it, he said I would have to use the app or go online. I was already driving so this was impossible. I have been going to YourPie in Palencia on my way from one job to another about once a week for a year now, but can’t anymore, unfortunately. Customer service makes a difference!

This place is the Subway of pizza. Everything is mediocre and you find yourself going because it's fast and nearby, or you're with someone picky that seems to e... read more This place is the Subway of pizza. Everything is mediocre and you find yourself going because it's fast and nearby, or you're with someone picky that seems to enjoy the over simplistic blandness of this place.Honestly, any of the major togo chains like Domino's or Papa are better. I'd recommend just biting the bullet and driving to Carmelos for a good classic pie or DeLeon for some Sicilian.

My kids and I love this place, it’s our favorite pizza around the World Gulf/Palencia area the staff is great too. The birthday cake gelato is so good.I had the... read more My kids and I love this place, it’s our favorite pizza around the World Gulf/Palencia area the staff is great too. The birthday cake gelato is so good.I had the Great White, hubby had a pepperoni, kids had a cheese, all of our pizzas were good.