The Black Fly - St. Augustine

We had a very pleasant evening with a fantastic menu. The price point was spot on for the high quality of food. A shout out to Ross a most friendly and knowledg... read more We had a very pleasant evening with a fantastic menu. The price point was spot on for the high quality of food. A shout out to Ross a most friendly and knowledgeable server. Will certainly be back.

First the good. The bartender was amazing. I totally forgot her name but she was very knowledgeable and friendly. They have a very nice selection of top shelf b... read more First the good. The bartender was amazing. I totally forgot her name but she was very knowledgeable and friendly. They have a very nice selection of top shelf bourbon, rum and tequila. Then we went to our table for dinner and it was not good after that. The waiter was horrible. He took forever to come to the table. Was not knowledgable about the menu. I ordered the chicken cordon blue it was so dry. I tried to eat it and could not, I had to ask for more sauce and that did not help. My husband told the server and he ordered me another one. The manager came over and apologized. Of course my husband was finished with his dinner by the time my new chicken came out. Neither the waiter or the manager came to see if the new one was good which it was better but not great. For the prices of the meals I would expect much better food and service. I will not be back and do not recommend this place. It is not worth the walk over the bridge. When we travel we always rely on open table reviews in selecting a restaurant it is important that people are honest with reviews.

Food was wonderful. Nice experience. I would definitely come back. Service was ok. read more Food was wonderful. Nice experience. I would definitely come back. Service was ok.

Everything was delicious! The steak was so tender I could cut it with a butter knife. Our waitress was super sweet. We'll be back for sure! read more Everything was delicious! The steak was so tender I could cut it with a butter knife. Our waitress was super sweet. We'll be back for sure!

Black fly is one of our favorite restaurants to visit when in St Augustine. Had another great meal and Ava was our server. She was great! Among the 4 of us we h... read more Black fly is one of our favorite restaurants to visit when in St Augustine. Had another great meal and Ava was our server. She was great! Among the 4 of us we had beef tenderloin, ahi tuna scallops…all cooked prepared perfectly. We’ll be back again on our next visit to this area.