Casey's - Menu

I enjoyed my experience at Casey's and decided to place a pickup order through the app. I ordered a Turkey Club sub, but unfortunately, the bacon was burnt inst... read more I enjoyed my experience at Casey's and decided to place a pickup order through the app. I ordered a Turkey Club sub, but unfortunately, the bacon was burnt instead of just crispy—a detail I didn't realize I had to specify. I used my Casey's cash and paid with my credit card, and now I feel quite cheated. I expected a better sandwich for my order. I have a 12-inch sub, and I've only eaten half of it as I wait for a response regarding this issue. It’s frustrating that I have to take the time to write this review and then go back to sort out getting a replacement or a refund. On a positive note, the deli counter staff was very nice, as they usually are, but I'm extremely disappointed with this food item. Casey's really needs to address this situation!

The restaurant offers good bagged ice, a decent selection of hard liquors, and pizza. However, there are many panhandlers in the parking lot, and the exterior o... read more The restaurant offers good bagged ice, a decent selection of hard liquors, and pizza. However, there are many panhandlers in the parking lot, and the exterior of the restaurant is quite unappealing. On the bright side, the inside is fine. Unfortunately, the soda machine has been broken for months, and several of the drink pumps are also out of order.