Spanaway Pizza Time

#14 - Mexican - Spanaway, Pizza, Gluten Free

Spanaway Pizza Time

Spanaway Pizza Time
3.3 / 5 (207 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Spanaway Pizza Time from Spanaway featuring all 4 menus and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Last update: 29.01.2026 from: Amanda

Images

Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food Spanaway Pizza Time Food

Feedback

★ 3.3 / 5 from 207 reviews

Was Melissa Davis at Spanaway Pizza Time a mag?
I always give this place a low score and I haven't had it on a while but we were desperate and went back...the pizza must have got a face-lift because it never tasted so stinking good. : View all feedback.

What Joey Combs dislikes about Spanaway Pizza Time:
Sometimes this is the best pizza in Puyallup/spanaway other times it's not even edible. At it's best it's inconsistent. The cheesy bread is never the same, they always forget the ranch(you pay for) sometimes undercooked. It can be delicious enough that we risk it at times. Got it tonight and wasn't impressed. Wendsday's seem to be the best day to order here. View all feedback.

jay-wavetouch
15.07.2024

Pizza is good but why do you list open hours until 10 pm of you're gonna call and refuse to deliver any pizza ordered at 9:15 pm after I already paid online. Change your hours if you don't want orders. This is false advertisement.

joey
15.07.2024

Sometimes this is the best pizza in Puyallup/spanaway other times it's not even edible. At it's best it's inconsistent. The cheesy bread is never the same, they always forget the ranch(you pay for) sometimes undercooked. It can be delicious enough that we risk it at times. Got it tonight and wasn't impressed. Wendsday's seem to be the best day to order here.

jesse-james-white-st
15.07.2024

Ordered online from Eatonville after a 3.7 mile hike and the estimate was nearly the exact time we’d need to get there. Got the auto email saying our order “should” be ready but never an actual confirmation. Food was ready when we arrived and still hot. The fried Mac and cheese was good, but the sauce didn’t taste anything like beer cheese. I ordered a thin crust but it it looked identical to my partners regular crust, so mine had a lot of crust. Good flavors, but too much crust.

amanda-frank-school7
15.07.2024

They don’t refund! Called in to order one pizza and was told that pizza will be ready for pickup in 35 minutes. Went to pick it up after 40 minuteshas passed. When I got inside I paid the cashier cash to pick up my order. After I paid and received my receipt they told me my pizza hasn’t been started yet and I will have to wait. I told them I called it in and was told it will be ready in 35 minutes. Therefore I asked for a refund because they wanted me to wait an additional 30 minutes since my order was not started. The lady so NO WE CANT REFUND YOUR MONEY. I stated but I just literally handed you cash and you gave me my receipt. She said nope. I was forced to get a pizza!!!! This is stealing from people at that point. Don’t come here they are never on time and they waited for me to pay them just to tell me my order hasn’t been started yet

edwa12d
15.07.2024

What's going on with the recipe?Every time I order a pizza now it's more like a deep dish. Crust is under cooked, a ton of tomato sauce and cheese that just falls off the slice straight to the floor.Pizza Time was go to place for the past 2 years for some Mom Pops pizza. Customer service is great, but the training the employees on how to make your delicious pie is lacking.On a one bite everybody knows the rules Scale went from 8.2 to a 3.5 for me.

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.