Pizza Plus and Subs - Simcoe

Pizza, Chicken, Delivery Services

Pizza Plus and Subs

Pizza Plus and Subs
2.9 / 5 (35 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Pizza Plus and Subs from Simcoe featuring all 4 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

A local pizza place garners mixed reviews from customers. Complaints range from burnt crusts and rude service to delayed orders and incorrect charges. On the flip side, loyal customers praise the friendly staff, generous toppings, and reasonable prices. It seems like a hit-or-miss experience at this establishment, with some recommending it for delicious pizza while others caution against potential issues with orders and service. Despite the inconsistency, the general consensus seems to be that the quality of the food is worth a try.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Images

Pizza Plus and Subs Food Pizza Plus and Subs Food

Feedback

★ 2.9 / 5 from 35 reviews

Was Anonym at Pizza Plus and Subs a mag?
I've been ordering there since I first tried it in febuary 2015. Friendly staff and great tasting pizza. Their topping are always generous and fresh. The prices are very reasonable as well. I would recommend it for sure. All the delivery guy needs is a smile! View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Pizza Plus and Subs:
Cardboard tasting crust and soggy. I found it very bland. The ppl behind the counter were jibering away in their language which I found very rude. I tried a sub too and the bread was stale with cheap cold cuts. That's enough for me no thanks. View all feedback.

The owner is extremely kind. The pizza is quite tasty and good pricing. They offer a whole assortment of things on their menu as well.

Super helpful and they delivered all the way to Horseshoe Valley Resort. The wings were good accordingly to the chicken wing experts amongst us.

For a quick and enjoyable weekend meal this is a sure bet. Very busy so service is a tad slow but well worth the wait. Always enjoyable.

It used to be our target for pizza wings. It's obviously new property. Order 2 large pizza wings, used to $45 with pop dips, is now $52 no pop, no dives. A pizza was ordered without cheese, it came with cheese, the other was Greek. Menu says Greek comes with chicken... no chicken. Really sad, was a good place, but we won't be back.

Best price to portion ratio round and consistently tasty. Owner is also very friendly. I'm going to Pizza in Barrie

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.