Subway - Sidney

Sandwiches, Cheese, Meat
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Subway

Subway
3.8 / 5 (140 reviews)

Description

Located off I-80, this Subway attempts to provide a friendly atmosphere in a charming log cabin setting, yet customer service remains a significant concern. Many patrons report frustrating drive-thru experiences with long waits, incorrect orders, and unhelpful staff. While some commend the cleanliness and prompt service of friendly employees, others express disappointment over poor attitudes and unfulfilled orders. Notably, the location struggles with inconsistent management; while some visitors enjoy well-prepared food, others find it lacking in quality and service. Ultimately, diners may want to consider alternate Subway locations for a more satisfying experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Tray

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 140 reviews
tray-jackson-1
26.10.2024

Honestly this has to be the nicest subway in the history of time. It’s in an old log cabin just off I 80. The staff was friendly, attentive and smiling. The entire dining area was spotless. The bathrooms were spotless. The food was what you would expect at any subway. Just a great sandwich.

jason-jokester-gibso-2
26.10.2024

Honest people!

carina
26.10.2024

Nice sized location. The outside and inside look great. There was only one worker and a tonne of tourists came through. I feel bad that the employee had to deal with so much at work once. Staffing should be increased to avoid over burdening your employees. Parking: Gravel parking could be difficult for those with walking aids

joshua-wesling
26.10.2024

Food was spot on fresh, place is clean, and the employees super friendly and I really enjoyed my visit and chatting . Keep it up!

business-acct
26.10.2024

I tried to call the two stores in Sidney to explain the the tomatoes on my sandwiches are rotten and to please dont serve them to anyone else!They staff could not understand me. They kept trying to take my order leaving off tomatoes.I called another store in julesburg colorado to tell them so they could use the info to warn somebody somehwere to not serve anymore damged rotten tomatoes.My stomach was very upset from eating the tomatoes on the sandwich. I would like to give the sandwiches back and get my money back but the staff does not understand. I dont want new sandwiches. I do not want to buy food from Subway again. When I photographed the tomatoes i could see how rotten they are.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.