Reviews
What OpenTable Diner likes about 18 Bay:
We had an amazing meal and the service was outstanding. Jimmy made us feel completely at home. Every restaurant on the island could learn a thing or two from 18 Bay. That's all there is to say! View all feedback.
What Natasha doesn't like about 18 Bay:
The food was excellent. The wine pairings very good. My only complaints would be the noise level and a feeling of being rushed, even though we were there for almost two hours. I think it goes with the territory of the limited choice menu, no surprises and everything is set to go in the kitchen. If it had been cooler and drier and we had eaten on the quieter and more intimate porch, I think these « comments » would be... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The restaurant has a unique charm, and the history of the building adds a lot of character. The service was friendly and accommodating. I really appreciate that...
read moreWhat a pleasure it was to visit 18 Bay! The entire experience was top-notch. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and efficient, and the wine list was extensi...
read moreWe had an incredible meal with outstanding service. Jimmy made us feel completely at home. Every restaurant on the island could learn a thing or two from 18 Bay...
read moreExtraordinary eating. all weine available by the glass. friendly, friendly staff (jimmy was great.) the otters on the antipasto were amazing!
Awesome Experience! Loved the wine pairings. Food was creative and delicious. We will be back!
The restaurant has a distinctive character, and the history of the building adds a lot to the experience. The service was warm and accommodating. I appreciate t...
read moreIt was a truly enjoyable experience dining at 18 Bay. Everything about it was top-notch. The staff was not only friendly but also knowledgeable and efficient. T...
read moreWe had an amazing meal and the service was outstanding. Jimmy made us feel completely at home. Every restaurant on the island could learn a thing or two from 18...
read moreExtraordinary food. All wines available by the glass. Friendly, welcoming staff (Jimmy was great). The otters on the antipasto were amazing !!
Great food, service and atmosphere as always. We have been going to 18 Bay for years and never been disappointed. Best restaurant on the island.