Stanfield’s Eatery - Sheffield

Bakery , American, Cheese

Stanfield’s Eatery

Stanfield’s Eatery
4.1 / 5 (180 reviews)

Description

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Corey

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 180 reviews
corey-patterson-1
25.02.2024

My wife and I decided to try this restaurant for a lunch date. The atmosphere is reminiscent of Cracker Barrel, featuring vintage decor and unique lighting. Unfortunately, the food did not meet our expectations. I ordered the steak and chicken with a loaded baked potato, while my wife chose the French toast. Our meals arrived fairly quickly, but the portion sizes were disappointing for the prices charged. The steak was about what you'd expect from a filet, but the chicken breast was quite small, and the baked potato was also tiny. The French toast appeared decent, but my wife remarked that it had a taste reminiscent of the grill. Despite finishing our meals, we both left feeling hungry, which is surprising considering our bill was $55. On a positive note, our server was excellent and attentive. Perhaps we just visited at an off time, but we had hoped for a better experience.

derek-south-2
25.02.2024

I've dined here multiple times since its reopening at the new location, and unfortunately, it doesn't quite measure up to what it used to be. The menu has expanded and includes some appealing options, but some of the classics are disappointing, particularly the cheeseburgers. The bun overpowers the burger, which seems to be a small frozen patty. On a positive note, the salad bar is still excellent. However, I'm disappointed that my favorite dish, the ribeye sandwich on Texas toast, is no longer available; they've replaced it with what looks like frozen garlic bread. It feels like the restaurant is trying to be fancier than necessary.

kristi-walker-2
25.02.2024

**Vegetarian Options:** They offer a variety of fresh salads and an impressive salad bar! **Parking:** The location is ideal, with ample parking available. The entrances and exits are easy to navigate. **Kid-Friendliness:** The atmosphere is welcoming for families, with numerous food choices for children. **Wheelchair Accessibility:** There’s plenty of parking, and the restaurant is all on one level. The doorways are spacious, and the table heights and seating arrangements are generally wheelchair accessible.

privacy-big-dog-priv
25.02.2024

WowWhat names of items on menu who is the smart onePurple skittleStarryDeath by chocolateReal professional team neededThe map is amazing

paula-eisengrein
25.02.2024

Freezing cold in dining area... had to wear coat and hat. Bakery server left us in the midst of waiting on us to talk on the phone and just left us hanging. Nobody waited on us after waiting a long time so we walked out.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.