Mr. Potato Spread - Sharpes

American, Steak, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Mr. Potato Spread

Mr. Potato Spread
4.2 / 5 (121 reviews)

Menu

On this homepage, you will find the complete menu of Mr. Potato Spread from Sharpes. Currently, there are 27 meals and drinks available.

Come experience authentic American cuisine at Mr Potato Spread in Jacksonville. Our menu features delicious specials that will keep you coming back for more. Contact us to reserve the best table in town.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: David

Images

Mr. Potato Spread Food Mr. Potato Spread Food Mr. Potato Spread Outside Mr. Potato Spread Menu Mr. Potato Spread Menu Mr. Potato Spread Food Mr. Potato Spread Drink Mr. Potato Spread Menu

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 121 reviews

Was Fonda Campbell at Mr. Potato Spread a mag?
Oh my goodness, this dish is absolutely amazing! It's like a low country boil served on a potato. It features fresh crab meat, shrimp, sausage, corn, eggs, garlic butter, Old Bay seasoning, and jalapeño cheese. My son created his own dish with steak, bacon, garlic butter, sour cream, ranch, and cheddar cheese! Both meals were a delightful 10 out of 10! While waiting for my car to be fixed at the dealership, I thought... View all feedback.

What Fonda Campbell dislikes about Mr. Potato Spread:
I'm not sure why my paragraph picture was removed or changed, but here’s my review: I ordered the chicken bacon ranch potato, and it really didn’t meet my expectations. The chicken was not good; it tasted like frozen, pre-cooked chicken that had just been heated up, rather than being freshly grilled. I couldn't finish it because of the taste and texture of the chicken. Overall, I was quite disappointed with the food... View all feedback.

sendal-stewart
03.02.2024

The best baked potato I've ever tasted! The staff were incredibly friendly and very helpful with the menu. My food was ready in just a few minutes!

fonda
27.12.2023

Oh my goodness, this dish is absolutely amazing! It's like a low country boil served on a potato. It features fresh crab meat, shrimp, sausage, corn, eggs, garlic butter, Old Bay seasoning, and jalapeño cheese. My son created his own dish with steak, bacon, garlic butter, sour cream, ranch, and cheddar cheese! Both meals were a delightful 10 out of 10! While waiting for my car to be fixed at the dealership, I thought it would be a good idea to order from Uber Eats, and I stumbled upon this little slice of heaven. The only downside was that the extra garlic butter was poured on top before I could snap a picture of all the deliciousness!

l-panda
03.02.2024

I've been wanting to try this restaurant for a while, and I finally went with some friends the other day. The staff was friendly, but unfortunately, the food was a letdown for most of us. The potatoes were burnt on the outside and barely warm on the inside, which suggests they had been prepared too far in advance and left to sit. One potato had a cold filling on top, preventing the cheese from melting. This indicates that the toppings weren't fresh either. Another potato was topped with what looked like ground beef, but it tasted more like a bad sloppy joe than a Philly cheesesteak. Overall, it was quite disappointing. A friend mentioned that the only redeeming dishes might be the seafood items. However, based on our experience, we won't be returning to try those, as we worry about food safety if they can’t get the basics right.

david-clemens-fish90
13.06.2025

Oh my goodness walked in when I saw this place from the parking lot and had no expectations. I ordered the crab pot on a sweet potato, and it was incredible. Quick and friendly service with hot and delicious food definitely recommend!

jenn-wiest-1
13.06.2025

Tried the crab pot potato today. It was so good. Plenty of shrimp and crab meat. Great flavor. I definitely will be visiting their new Phillips Highway location again!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.