Papa's Pizza - Sewell

We absolutely love the wings here. The pizza is decent - not great, but not terrible either. However, the wings are definitely the highlight of our visits!

The service was poor. I inquired about whether they offered thin crust pizzas, and the server responded that all their pizzas were thin crust. So, I ordered a thin crust pizza with mushrooms. It took 40 minutes to arrive. If I hadn’t already paid, I would have left without eating. When I finally got home, I found that it was a soggy crust pizza with hardly any sauce or cheese, and I could barely count the uncooked mushrooms on it. This will be my first and last experience at this restaurant.

Posting your political beliefs outside your restaurant may be one of the worst things a business can do. I only had a voucher, but I found the pizza to be small and below average, and the wings were soggy.

Terrible service. ordered a Sicilian pizza over the phone without any problems. The girl on the phone even said it back to us and told us it would be ready in 20 minutes. We'll pick them up and tell us we never ordered them. We order again and wait in the car as we have to wait again. She comes out a few minutes later and says they don't have Sicilian pizzas anymore and our first order, but for a regular pizza. So unprofessional and unprofessional. If my friend wasn't so hungry, we would have gone. Never recommend this place because of its bad service.

Slices of pizza are HUGE! The mega fries that I had were good, unfortunately the serving I had was baked too long so it was a little burned and super crunchy. There was a man working there talking loudly about politics and cursing, but that could be the norm for all I know. I was visiting from Oklahoma City, so New Jersey is always a little culture shock for me. Overall good food. Atmosphere was just okay.