Gemmes General Store - Sebago

Seafood, Pizza, Store

Nestled along Sebago Lake’s picturesque shore, this charming eatery combines a quaint general store vibe with a menu that delights. Diners rave about the generously sized sandwiches, particularly the steak subs, which boast thick cuts of juicy meat and are often large enough to share. The culinary offerings extend to massive pizzas and delectable chicken finger platters, perfect for family outings. Although some menu items may lean towards the higher price range, many patrons feel the quality justifies the cost. With a cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and nearby outdoor seating, this hidden gem is a must-visit for food lovers.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Patti

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 50 reviews

Was Norwood Hessel at Gemmes General Store a mag?
The cheese steak subs are out of this world. Deliciously satisfying with probably a pound of meat on it. Wicked good and definitely recommended. The cold cut subs are equally satisfying. The prices are high but worth it for the quality and quantity!!! View all feedback.

What Silly S dislikes about Gemmes General Store:
I visited the restaurant today after hearing positive reviews, but I was extremely disappointed. It seems like they are exploiting their beachfront location and the fact that they are the only food option in the area. The sandwich I ordered was terrible and overpriced at $18.99. I don't think I need to say much more, just take a look at the photo. View all feedback.