West Seattle Farmers Market

Cocktail, American, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for West Seattle Farmers Market.

West Seattle Farmers Market

West Seattle Farmers Market
4.4 / 5 (1205 reviews)

Menu

The menu of West Seattle Farmers Market from Seattle includes 66 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $18.6. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Haymaker West Seattle is the latest addition from the General Harvest Restaurant group. Our menu features a variety of fresh seafood, local vegetables, proteins, and delicious pasta dishes. Drawing inspiration from our Italian restaurants, we are bringing a simplistic approach to new American cuisine.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Benjamin

Images

West Seattle Farmers Market Food West Seattle Farmers Market Drink West Seattle Farmers Market Food West Seattle Farmers Market Food West Seattle Farmers Market Inside West Seattle Farmers Market Food West Seattle Farmers Market Food

Reservation request for West Seattle Farmers Market

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 1205 reviews

Haymaker has garnered mixed reviews, with diners praising some dishes while expressing disappointment in service and overall experience. While select entrees like black cod and pork shine, reports of small portions and bland flavors for the price are frequent. Service inconsistencies, such as lengthy waits for drinks and a rushed dining experience, have left guests feeling undervalued. However, the restaurant does receive commendations for its creative cocktails and vibrant atmosphere. Overall, while some guests had delightful meals, others felt that Haymaker fell short of expectations, making repeat visits uncertain for many.

evy-yuksel
10.01.2024

We had high expectations for Haymaker, but unfortunately, we were let down. Things started off well when we arrived a few minutes early for our reservation and were seated promptly. However, things went downhill from there. It took 20 minutes for our drinks to arrive after ordering, despite notifying our server that we were in a time crunch. Only one slider out of three per order was brought to us, with no explanation on when we would receive the rest. Our entrees arrived with less than 15 minutes to eat and pay, even though the restaurant was not even half full. With only two servers working and our server being hardly present, the open kitchen seemed chaotic. The pasta was undercooked to the point of being Al dente. When we provided feedback to the front of house manager on our way out, he blamed us for not making an earlier reservation.

pribitsh63
10.01.2024

Absolutely amazing restaurant. It was recommended by a friend. I wanted to find a good, high quality restaurant in West Seattle located near bookstores and Easy Street Records. It was perfect. And, wow! The best restrooms I've ever seen.

sohil-devkota
10.01.2024

We should have sent our food back it was so over spiced. If I was the chef tasting the tagliatelle I would’ve thrown out the whole batch. It was Thai food spicy.

benjamin-fox-shapiro-1
02.06.2025

My review is from the perspective of a vegetarian, so others could probably ignore. There aren’t many vegetarian options on the menu and I had most of them. The eggplant and heirloom tomato appetizers are fantastic, and the only reason I am giving 3stars instead of just 1 or 2. They clearly know how to prepare vegetables and it would be great if they had other dishes thatplaced them at the center. I get that it’s a nice restaurant but charging $8 for 4 slices of bread seems steep. The fusilli isthe only vegetarian entree, and the pasta itself was good and it had nice fresh and flavorful vegetables in it but it wasdampened by a too-rich butter sauce.

laki-vlachos
02.06.2025

Had a great Father's Day brunch here with some tasty dishes! Steak and Eggs, Croque Madam, Carbonara, and Pancakes! The biscuits were also delicious!

  • Chefs Choice Tasting Menu

    4 Courses To Share (Priced Per Person)
    4 Courses To Share (Priced Per Person)
    $78.5
  • Starters

    G.h. Focaccia
    G.h. Focaccia
    $7.9
  • Selections

    Haymaker Salad
    Haymaker Salad
    $13.9
  • Dessert

    Seasonal Sorbet Or Gelato
    Seasonal Sorbet Or Gelato
    $7.9
  • Pasta

    Creste De Gallo
    Creste De Gallo
    $26.8
  • Salads

    Apple Beet Salad
    Apple Beet Salad
    $15.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.