Reviews
What Cynthia Z likes about The Penny Ice Creamery:
This is still one of my all-time favorite ice cream shops. The bitter caramel flavor is absolutely amazing and, in my opinion, truly iconic. If you want to take your experience up a notch, try it with the burnt marshmallow. The texture can be a bit inconsistent, but that doesn't bother me; it's just a result of not using additives like emulsifiers and gums. It might be a little icy, but it adds to its charm. Please d... View all feedback.
What Shamsah N doesn't like about The Penny Ice Creamery:
The ice cream is super expensive for a very small quantity. I was shocked when the server handed me the scoops. The flavors might be good but you get 2 bites for 5. I won't be returning. Better off going to another place that has decent flavors and a decent quantity. Not worth the View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Service and flavors were great. Was told that Penny Ice Creamery teams up with local farms for some of the ingredients in their ice creams (awesome). This locat...
read moreInteresting, delicious and one of a kind flavors. Love the toasted marshmallow topping! Delicious ice cream and genuine customer service.
In short, Disappointed. With a few more details, Saw this place on social media and I was fooled. I thought it would be real good but the ice cream was sub par...
read moreWe had a double scooped top with toasted marshmallows. I chose bitter caramel and mascarpone hazelnuts, they were both good, sweet, rich in flavor but also ligh...
read moreTalk about fresh!!! The waffle cones were made the day I was there, and the ice cream flavor I had was made the day before with real organic ingredients (no pre...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more