Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Stephanie Y likes about The Penny Ice Creamery:
My son wanted at that marshmallow topping I've been telling him about. An outpost of the Santa Cruz legend, Penny Creamery, we found street parking and popped into this very small ice cream shop. $5.50 for a golf ball size $6.50 for a baseball size. Pricey, but they use fresh and quality ingredient. The mint chip tastes as if you are eating fresh mint! The lovely lady helping us was friendly, although definitely a bi... View all feedback.
What Shamsah N doesn't like about The Penny Ice Creamery:
The ice cream is super expensive for a very small quantity. I was shocked when the server handed me the scoops. The flavors might be good but you get 2 bites for 5. I won't be returning. Better off going to another place that has decent flavors and a decent quantity. Not worth the View all feedback.
Best ice cream in the bay. I I love the marshmallow fluff. Kid loved it to with sprinkles and Tahitian vanilla bean with strawberry sorbet. Always busy and there's a line but definitely worth the wait. It goes by quick anyways. Staff is friendly and all are sweet.
Great ice cream if you find a flavor you like. It's pretty limited and some flavors are weird (basil? we got the vanilla and coffee they were amazing. 5.5 dollars for a small scoop. They make the waffles in house. Go to the bathroom and check the spoons display
Still one of my favorite ice cream places (ever). Bitter caramel is insanely good and imo the most iconic. If you wanna bring it to the next level, order with burnt marshmallow. The texture isn't always consistent but it doesn't bother me that's what happens when you don't use chemicals such as emulsifiers and gum. A little icy, extra charming. Please don't change a thing in the recipes!
This place had a line, so you know it's good. And it was, the affogato was amazing, and we enjoy the other mash up of verve coffee with chocolate covered almonds.
The ice cream is super expensive for a very small quantity. I was shocked when the server handed me the scoops. The flavors might be good but you get 2 bites for 5. I won't be returning. Better off going to another place that has decent flavors and a decent quantity. Not worth the
More information
QR-code link to the menu
