Paragon Deli Cafe - Feedback

It was before 7AM and it was open, walked in to fresh, hot and tasty coffee, owner was really pleasant, kitchen is very clean, food selection is waiting to be e...

Chocolate chip cookies, carrot cake, and fabulous sandwiches are made here. Best deli in all our 12 years of full time traveling. Helen’s smile makes the custom...

Great sandwiches, salads and pastries. Very friendly staff and attentive to customer needs and questions.

Above and beyond 5 Stars. The steak and onion sandwich was amazing and the staff was super friendly. I don 't normally comment on restrooms, but they had an ast...

Ordered breakfast sandwiches to go. Absolutely delicious! Great customer service too. Highly recommend. We want to go back for lunch now and try a salad.

This place was just a quick stop before going on a whale watching tour. Super friendly staff, amazing food that I'm still thinking about days later, and honestl...

We stopped in yesterday and had the pleasure of enjoying the most delicious Eggs Benedict we ever had. Everything was cooked to perfection. The Hollandaise sauc...

Best **** Mary's made by Steve. The staff and customer service is top notch. Cute cafe located on Shelter Island. Will always support local small businesses. Fo...

Cute and quaint cafe with excellent salad and sandwiches. We had the German Sausage sandwich and CA Cobb salad- both were delicious and big portions. Will defin...

Finding ParAgon Deli Cafe was an unexpected treat. The food was so incredibly good and the restaurant and clean and quaint. We will definitely make our way back...