Atlantic Grill - Rye

This place was incredible!! The food was absolutely amazing, and the service was fantastic. I ordered a special martini that wasn’t on the menu, and not only di... read more This place was incredible!! The food was absolutely amazing, and the service was fantastic. I ordered a special martini that wasn’t on the menu, and not only did they agree to make it, they made it perfectly!! It was so good. The sushi was ridiculously good, and the potstickers and crab cakes were the perfect appetizers to share. We will absolutely be back whenever we’re in the area again.

So loved the garden like dining experience, it was like being in Europe. read more So loved the garden like dining experience, it was like being in Europe.

Great food and the lobster was excellent. Superb and friendly service. read more Great food and the lobster was excellent. Superb and friendly service.

Always a pleasant dining experience. Food consistently great read more Always a pleasant dining experience. Food consistently great

This is my first time ever writing a Google review. I dined here for the 2nd time the other night. I was reluctant to return since my first visit was underwhelm... read more This is my first time ever writing a Google review. I dined here for the 2nd time the other night. I was reluctant to return since my first visit was underwhelming. They have created a great atmosphere here and the staff is lovely. Though my experience with their food has been disappointing. For the price point, I expect a higher quality product than what I've received. My swordfish was okay, and the vegetables on the side were lacking any notable flavors. The other member of our party ordered the haddock or halibut, I believe, and she ended up sending it back. It was undercooked and also devoid of any flavor. The manager removed that meal from our check and handled everything gracefully. For an establishment that's been around as long as the Atlantic Grill, I expect a certain level of excellence. Based on all the five star reviews on here, it's possible that I've just caught them on a bad night. Unfortunately, I won't be returning here to see if the third time is the charm.