Righteous Slice - Rexburg

#19 - Pizza - Rexburg, American, North American

Righteous Slice, a beloved American restaurant in Rexburg, ID, offers a delightful dining experience with an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, it's the perfect spot for both intimate dinners for two and lively gatherings with friends and family. To ensure you have a table ready, give them a call at (208) 820 4597 to reserve your spot. Prefer dining at home? You can conveniently order through DoorDash and enjoy their delicious offerings right from your couch. With a diverse menu that includes vegetarian options, there's something to satisfy every palate. If you're looking for late-night bites, Righteous Slice has you covered. For an alternative dining experience, consider visiting Rocky Mountain Chocolate Factory Rexburg or Five Guys. Have you had the pleasure of dining here before? Share your experience with a review!.

Last update: 20.12.2025 from: Elias

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 89 reviews

Righteous Slice turns out inventive, brick-oven pizzas—Neapolitan and New York styles—made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and bold flavors. Generous signature shakes and large salads complement a trendy, lively atmosphere with friendly staff and fast service. Praised for creativity, consistency and value, it’s a local destination ideal for dates, groups or pizza lovers. Expect busy, noisy evenings and the occasional soggy center on heavily topped thin pies.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Righteous slice is the best freaking pizza in Idaho. It?s brick oven cooked with actual fire and the pizzas are super creative. The bee sting is my favorite pizza to get but you can?t go wrong with any of their menu options. The owner has a passion for his pizza and his customers. I?ve eaten here probably over 15 times and I?ve never been disappointed. It?s a great date place too! Break away from the chains of chain restaurants and get yourself some really amazing food.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

We drove an hour to get here and it was totally worth it. The staff was super friendly and nice. They helped us order after hearing it was our first time. The salad was HUGE and we split it. The strawberries on it were perfect and it was so fresh and delicious. We each got the same pizza but changed out the cheese. My daughter got the shredded and I got the fresh mozzarella. They told us that the fresh mozzarella is made right there. We did a taste test and both were actually outstanding. The food comes out in five minutes so nobody goes hungry long. Great value, amazing people, and lovely location. We recommend it!!!

Aiden 02.04.2025 - 01:30

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

This place kills it! We come a couple times per month and have only ever ordered a Neapolitan styled pizza, however we branches out (yes we just got cheese and pep) and it was awesome. The New York style is definitely something worth ordering and waitingfor! Everything is fresh and made with love. The environment is fun and inviting. I will for sure be buying more New York Stylepizza in the future! 10 out of 10

Elias 02.04.2025 - 01:30

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Got one of their New York style pizzas, and it was a phenomenal experience. A delightful blend of flavors that gave a new experience with each bite. By far the best pizza in town

Kevin 02.04.2025 - 01:30

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Awesome firewood Pizza, loved the margarita, God Father and the NY Cheese Pizza!! You should try this place.

Feedback