Casey's - Rensselaer

#10 - Seafood - Rensselaer, #22 - Mexican - Rensselaer, Asiatic
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
4.2 / 5 (948 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Casey's from Rensselaer comprises about 108 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $16.4 for a dish / drink.

Casey's Restaurant, located in Rensselaer, NY, is a highly regarded American dining spot, featuring an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Diners rave about the warm atmosphere and exceptional service. Stop by for lunch from 11:30 AM to 2:00 PM, and don’t forget to call ahead at (518) 463-3318 to check on availability or reserve a table. For those who prefer to enjoy their favorite dishes at home, Casey's offers convenient ordering through Uber Eats. Don’t miss out on their fantastic beer selection, which perfectly complements your meal. If you're looking for other options nearby, consider Stewart's Shops and Nelsons Steak Out for a similar dining experience. If you’ve dined at Casey's before, we’d love to hear your thoughts!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Loretta

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Drink Casey's Menu Casey's Menu Casey's Food Casey's Food

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 948 reviews

Caseys, a restaurant known for its great food, recently underwent new ownership that unfortunately resulted in a disappointing experience for some diners. From delayed drinks to poorly cooked dishes, there were several complaints about the food quality and service. On the flip side, there were also positive reviews highlighting the friendly staff, outstanding food, and generous portions. Despite some setbacks, Caseys continues to draw customers back with its warm atmosphere and accommodating service. However, recent changes in operating hours due to staffing issues have left some patrons disappointed, hoping for a return to normal operations soon.

a-user-31
15.09.2023

Good food and service. Generous portions. Very accommodating with offering gluten free options. Server was attentive and friendly.Dietary restrictions: Offered Gluten free: steak, fries (we were the first to order on this day), shrimp cocktail, chocolate mouse

tremayne29
15.09.2023

Appetizers were very good calamari, spinach/ricotta wontons, pork belly sliders. Main courses were hit or miss. Hazelnut chicken was dry and overcooked. Chicken riggies was okay but nothing special. Our server was polite and attentive. Not as a good under the new ownership.Food: 3/5

joe-68
15.09.2023

Plentiful parking, relaxing atmosphere, attentive and pleasant waitstaff. Warm bread and fresh salads preceded our delicious entrees. Our first dining experience at Casey’s was a 10 out of 10.

loretta-h-horse2
08.03.2024

It's been a while since I last visited Casey's. My partner and I decided to stop by for lunch recently. The interior is charming, adorned with clocks...

sharon-w-bank7947
08.03.2024

DISCLAIMER: I genuinely want Casey's to thrive! I’m a local resident and have been visiting this restaurant for years. I was aware that there has been a change in ownership and the chef...

  • Casey'S A La Carte

    House Salad And Caesar Salad A La Carte
    House Salad And Caesar Salad A La Carte

    Served + the purchase of dinner Entree.

    $3.2
  • Pasta

    Pasta With Chicken Riggies
    Pasta With Chicken Riggies

    Traditional utica style. Spicy tomato vodka cream sauce; + sauteed chicken; mushrooms; & pepperoncini. tossed + rigatoni & topped + melted Parmesan & mozzarella cheese.

    $21.8
    Tortellini Carbonaro
    Tortellini Carbonaro

    Cheese Tortellini sauteed + garlic; shallots; bacon; basil; marinara sauce; & cream; finished in the oven topped + provolone cheese.

    $20.8
    Pasta With Chicken And Sausage
    Pasta With Chicken And Sausage
    $20.8
  • Steaks

    Traditional Calves Liver Steak
    Traditional Calves Liver Steak

    Seasoned & pan seared; topped off + caramelized onions & hickory smoked bacon.

    $16.8
  • Burger

    3. Burger With American Cheese
    3. Burger With American Cheese

    Caramelized sweet onion & crispy bacon.

    $11.8

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.