Sherwood Inn - Port Carling

Had 2 wonderful meals from this place. My filet mignon was done to perfection and had a tasty array of roasted vegetables. My wife's stuffed chicken was also delicious and rave worthy. Excellent wine selection and good service in a peaceful and lovely setting. My only complaint would be that the carpet needed some vacuuming because there was food all over it, and we ate at the first sitting of the evening.

Really enjoy going here over the decades. Not as nice as it used to be, but still is pleasant to go for dinner. Enjoy the grounds and walking around.

I was here for a night with a few friends. Had dinner at Vintages. Started with the caesar salad. On the menu it said bacon was in the salad but there was so little it I had a hard time finding it. The dressing was good though. I also had the gnocchi. It was just ok. No real flavour popped out at me. The reason I'm giving 4 stars is because we brought our own wine and they waived the corkage fee. Thought that was a nice touch. Would I go back? If i was staying at the resort, I would give the restaurant another go and try something else on the menu.

My husband and I just spent two nights at Sherwood Inn. The inn has an old Muskoka feel and it situated on a great spot on Lake Joseph. If you are looking for a traditional Muskoka experience you will find it here, not at the The Rosseau (Marriott), which is gorgeous, but has an entirely different feel. We saw only a few children during our stay. We had a premium Cedarwood room with a gorgeous waterfront view from a very large window. The king bed was very comfortable. There was no private outdoor space with this particular room, but that didn't bother us as there are a number of outdoor seating areas located throughout the property. We ate every meal at the inn (from Friday lunch until Sunday breakfast). We had dinner on Friday night on the outdoor patio and ordered from the lounge menu. We had dinner on Saturday night in the main dining room. Every meal was terrific. Service was fantastic throughout our entire stay. Every employee we dealt with could not have been friendlier. The outdoor music by Peter Noonan on Friday from 6 to 9pm was absolutely amazing. We truly enjoyed our stay and will definitely return.

The menu choices are excellent; presentation was superb and service was wonderful. Our server had excellent suggestions regarding our menu choices.