Reviews
What Paige Mews doesn't like about Gay Nineties Pizza Co:
First time to eating here, was greeted by Connor . Had high hopes as I’ve heard really good things about this place . We ordered our pizza for pick up half Maui half tomato and basil. When we got home the pizza was watery, there was not enough cheese . I think it was the sauce that was the problem . It was all merged together so we had to recut it. And then when u picked up each piece it fell apart. It was tasty but... View all feedback. What jjrmfun likes about Gay Nineties Pizza Co:
Good local pizza joint with tavern/bar area. Good pizza and fabulous salad. They make their own salad dressing and was fabulous. Bartender made Great recommendation for dinner and provided great service. Nice to have a comfortable small Town pizzaria when traveling to large city. Definitely will go back next time I am in Pleasanton. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Unbelievably bad service from the wait staff…not attentive, paid no attention to our not having the pizza 40 minutes after ordering. We could not get her attent...
read moreThis place is great, with an old time atmosphere and great pizza Good for family good service Sausage and peperoni is the bomb
We have lived around the world, having spent the last 15 years in the bay area. Gay Nineties is simply put the BEST! We remember bringing our 4 year old nephew...
read moreOur friends recommended this restaurant to us, and we were not disappointed. The pizza was among the best I've ever tasted, reminiscent of authentic Italian piz...
read moreThe young couple that owns and runs this place is a pleasure to do business with. The pizza is excellent and consistent. Quality food. Love this place. They app...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreGay Nineties Pizza offers a mixed dining experience according to patrons. Some rave about the excellent pizza, quality food, and friendly service provided by the young owners. Others express disappointment in the high prices, greasy pizza, and surly staff. The restaurant, located in downtown Pleasanton, has unique features such as a haunted corner booth and a historic underground doorway. While some enjoy the ambiance and history, others are put off by the bad service and food quality. Overall, opinions are divided, making it a hit or miss spot for those looking for a memorable dining experience in Pleasanton.
We came here as a group for a birthday party. It was super packed but got seated quickly. It was very good pizza! Fresh ingredients and nice dough. The complime...
read moreAbsolutely freaking amazing service and the food was banger. Will be back for sure and would absolutely recommend it to anyone.
New to town, Second time coming to this place. First time was OK thought I’d give it a second shot only to be disappointed bad service. The salad was good. The...
read moreThis was my favorite place for pizza in the east bay! I love the all meat with extra thick crust and would last me several days for lunch. After moving to Reno...
read moreI went for pizza because it is a place from the 90's but it takes a long time for the food to arrive at the table, in particular it is no longer the place it wa...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreToo hot to cook and wanted something delicious PIZZA was the choice While we've eaten here many times this what is the first time we order takeout.
I used to go here as a kid very frequently growing up in Pleasanton.
Always my favorite pizza place! We drive from Livermore just for pizzaPlus a great family environment.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more