Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What jjrmfun likes about Gay Nineties Pizza Co:
Good local pizza joint with tavern/bar area. Good pizza and fabulous salad. They make their own salad dressing and was fabulous. Bartender made Great recommendation for dinner and provided great service. Nice to have a comfortable small Town pizzaria when traveling to large city. Definitely will go back next time I am in Pleasanton. View all feedback.
What Paige Mews doesn't like about Gay Nineties Pizza Co:
First time to eating here, was greeted by Connor . Had high hopes as I’ve heard really good things about this place . We ordered our pizza for pick up half Maui half tomato and basil. When we got home the pizza was watery, there was not enough cheese . I think it was the sauce that was the problem . It was all merged together so we had to recut it. And then when u picked up each piece it fell apart. It was tasty but... View all feedback.
We came here as a group for a birthday party. It was super packed but got seated quickly. It was very good pizza! Fresh ingredients and nice dough. The complimentary bread was a lil overcooked but that's fine cuz we were so hungry that we devoured it as we waited for the pizza haha. I've never been here before but will definitely come back... They also have an outdoor patio but the day we went end of July it was too hot even in the evening.
Absolutely freaking amazing service and the food was banger. Will be back for sure and would absolutely recommend it to anyone.
I went for pizza because it is a place from the 90's but it takes a long time for the food to arrive at the table, in particular it is no longer the place it was years ago
Best pizza in the East Bay. My family has been coming here for years and the quality of the food is always consistent. They also have our favorite zucchini sticks at any restaurant.
This place had a real comfortable vibe, funny story how I found it. The server was really nice and informative.
Full Menu
Coffee
Salads
Soups
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
More information
QR-code link to the menu
