Reviews - Fireside Caterer
Reviews summary
Fireside Caterers of Plainview has garnered a blend of positive and negative feedback in recent reviews. Customers praise the friendly staff and the delicious, fresh food offered in both individual and buffet styles. The restaurant is appreciated for its creative daily hot food specials and clean environment. However, some long-time patrons have expressed disappointment at the noticeable decline in portion sizes and food quality since the original ownership changed, alongside concerns about pricing. While some dishes remain well-received, the inconsistency in experience has prompted calls for a return to the establishment's former charm and menu excellence.
Was Kayden Feeney at Fireside Caterer a mag?
Fireside Caterer features an excellent selection of hot and cold dishes, such as chopped salads and sandwiches. It's a great place for lunch, with staff that are always welcoming and friendly. View all feedback.
What Katrina Murazik dislikes about Fireside Caterer:
I have been visiting Fireside Caterer for thirty years, and I've observed a noticeable reduction in the size of their famous sandwiches. What was once a generous portion now feels insufficient. This unexpected change in portion sizes has been disappointing. Additionally, since the original owners departed, the quality of the food has dwindled. The flavors are no longer as delightful as they once were. It appears they... View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 19.08.2025
It’s a nice deli. You wouldn’t thinks it’s as nice inside as it is from the outside. The staff is nice and friendly.
Last update : 17.06.2023
Great staff, great selections of food and drinks . Clean and organized place
Good food, reasonable prices and a nice assortment of hot and cold food.
I really enjoy the fresh and tasty rolls at this restaurant, but I find the prices to be a bit too high for everything else on the menu. If you can afford it, I'm sure the food is delicious.
Fireside Caterers in Plainview is outstanding! The staff is not only attractive but also exceptionally friendly. We hired them for several corporate events, and they offered both individual meals and buffet options. The food is delicious and incredibly fresh. Best of all, Fireside is very affordable!
Fireside Caterer features an excellent selection of hot and cold dishes, such as chopped salads and sandwiches. It's a great place for lunch, with staff that are always welcoming and friendly.
Last update : 01.08.2022
Busy.. usually clean.. fresh food hot and cold
The food is delicious, the cole slaw with french fries and a rotisserie chicken are my personal favorite.
This place is incredible. They change up their hot food specials every day. I don't even both checking what they're serving before going in they always have something amazing.The service is excellent, and the whole place is kept very clean.
Excellent lunch spot with a wide variety of hot food options and friendly and attentive staff. Perfect for a quick meal of any kind.
Fireside caterers of plainview is amazing! they have the most beautiful, friendly staff. we used them to accompany some of our corporate events. they make individual meals and buffet style meals. you eat is delicious and fresh. fireside is also very cheap!
