Fireside Caterer - Plainview
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Fireside Caterer in Plainview. At the moment, there are 12 dishes and drinks on the menu.
Fireside Caterers of Plainview has garnered a blend of positive and negative feedback in recent reviews. Customers praise the friendly staff and the delicious, fresh food offered in both individual and buffet styles. The restaurant is appreciated for its creative daily hot food specials and clean environment. However, some long-time patrons have expressed disappointment at the noticeable decline in portion sizes and food quality since the original ownership changed, alongside concerns about pricing. While some dishes remain well-received, the inconsistency in experience has prompted calls for a return to the establishment's former charm and menu excellence.
Images
Feedback
Was Kayden Feeney at Fireside Caterer a mag?
This restaurant offers a variety of hot and cold dishes, including chopped salads and sandwiches. It's a fantastic spot for lunch with consistently friendly staff. View all feedback.
What Katrina Murazik dislikes about Fireside Caterer:
I have been coming to this restaurant for thirty years and have noticed a significant decrease in the size of their famous sandwiches. What used to be a large portion is now considered inadequate. This change in portion size was unexpected and informative. Unfortunately, the quality of the food has also declined since the original owners left. The flavors are not as good as they used to be. It seems like they need to... View all feedback.
Great staff, great selections of food and drinks . Clean and organized place
Good food, reasonable prices and a nice assortment of hot and cold food.
I really enjoy the fresh and tasty rolls at this restaurant, but I find the prices to be a bit too high for everything else on the menu. If you can afford it, I'm sure the food is delicious.
It’s a nice deli. You wouldn’t thinks it’s as nice inside as it is from the outside. The staff is nice and friendly.
Fireside Caterer features an excellent selection of hot and cold dishes, such as chopped salads and sandwiches. It's a great place for lunch, with staff that are always welcoming and friendly.
Full Menu
Mexican Street Tacos
Salad
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
Side Dishes
From The Grill
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.5 / 5 (2060 reviews)Pizza Italian Bar-lounge Wine CoffeeIavarone Italian Kitchen Pizzeria
Old Country Road 1575, 11803 Plainview, US
"Food is fantastic, as always. Many great options to chose from."
★ 4.5 / 5 (2372 reviews)Pizza Italian Pizzeria Lunch CheeseMama Lino's Pizzeria
595 Old Country Rd, Plainview, United States
"This is the best pizza I have ever had! The crust is thin and cooked to perfection, and the cheese and sauce are incredible. My go-to pizza is the Chi..."
★ 4.3 / 5 (3263 reviews)American North American CasualPantano's Eatery
South Oyster Bay Road 347, 11803 Plainview, US
"The BEST omelet I've ever tasted"