Old Trail Grill - Reviews

The wings are amazing at this place. We've been actually been impressed with everything we've eaten here. The reason I gave 4 stars is because it always seems u... read more The wings are amazing at this place. We've been actually been impressed with everything we've eaten here. The reason I gave 4 stars is because it always seems under staffed and service is always slow. I called in pick up and have arrived a little after the given time for pick up and had to wait another 20 min. for food to be ready. The staff is always friendly, but even before covid service always seemed slow and waitresses always blamed it on no help. Highly suggest dropping by to dine because the food is good but make sure you have plenty of time.

Great broasted chicken with all you can eat mashed potatoes and green beans with fried biscuits and apple butter special on Sunday. Not that I needed any extra... read more Great broasted chicken with all you can eat mashed potatoes and green beans with fried biscuits and apple butter special on Sunday. Not that I needed any extra sides after two pieces of chicken. A fantastic meal at a more than reasonable price. Not local to me, but willing to travel from Indy to visit again.

Had never had a bad experience here! the waitress is amazing and much more than her title! she really does a super job every time. you can't go wrong here! read more Had never had a bad experience here! the waitress is amazing and much more than her title! she really does a super job every time. you can't go wrong here!

The food was absolutely fantastic—served hot, and I finished every bite! I'm definitely going back. This is exactly why I love trying out non-chain restaurants... read more The food was absolutely fantastic—served hot, and I finished every bite! I'm definitely going back. This is exactly why I love trying out non-chain restaurants and supporting local businesses. I ordered the Breasted Chicken Meal, and it was delicious. They’re also getting new TVs, so you can enjoy football games and more while spending time with family or friends.

Three out of the four of us ordered the broasted chicken, while I opted for their tenderloin salad dressed with their homemade French dressing. They also offer... read more Three out of the four of us ordered the broasted chicken, while I opted for their tenderloin salad dressed with their homemade French dressing. They also offer homemade ranch. The service was a bit slow, likely because there was only one waitress on duty. However, much of the food is made from scratch, which enhances the experience.

Mostly populated with an older crowd that shows up for the food. I really enjoyed the chicken salad club. The space is quiet and cool with just enough breeze. T... read more Mostly populated with an older crowd that shows up for the food. I really enjoyed the chicken salad club. The space is quiet and cool with just enough breeze. There is no smoking inside and the bathroom is clean. The staff is friendly, all female, and not afraid to work hard.

Best fried chicken I've had in Indiana. We went on Thursday for the all you can eat chicken wings. As long as you don't eat besides you can really pig out on th... read more Best fried chicken I've had in Indiana. We went on Thursday for the all you can eat chicken wings. As long as you don't eat besides you can really pig out on these giant wings. At 11.99 for ayce it's a great value.

Never had a bad experience here!!! The waitress is amazing and much more than her title!!! She really does a super job each and every time. Dine in or take out,... read more Never had a bad experience here!!! The waitress is amazing and much more than her title!!! She really does a super job each and every time. Dine in or take out, you can't go wrong here!!

They have the best food. The weekly specials are something you need to have in your life. I wish I had the recipe for their chicken and noodles. I would love to... read more They have the best food. The weekly specials are something you need to have in your life. I wish I had the recipe for their chicken and noodles. I would love to make it for Christmas. I will keep coming back.