Peekskill Brewery - Feedback

#40 - Mexican - Peekskill, Brewery, Pubs

Reviews

Overall Total Score
3.7 out of 5
Very good | 5080 reviews

Was 5Kenneth C (2 1 year ago at Peekskill Brewery a mag?
Peekskill Brewery was incredible! After a three-hour hike nearby, my future brother-in-law and I stopped by for food and drinks, and it exceeded our expectations. The beer lineup was excellent, and the food was top-notch. They even have vegan choices for those with dietary needs. View all feedback.

What 3Justin S (2 4 months ago dislikes about Peekskill Brewery:
The ambiance is wonderful, and the beer is top-notch! Unfortunately, the food is only mediocre—nothing really stands out. I wouldn't recommend trying the cocktails, as they're quite disappointing. My biggest issue, however, is the pricing, which is similar to what you'd expect in the city. For example, burgers are priced at $20, and cocktails are $18. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Int Restaurants

Last update : 17.06.2023

3.9 ★ from 3077 reviews
eden24-1
17.06.2023

Great Post Bicycle Stop for fuelling a long ride. Can't go wrong with one of the burgers. Surprisingly, they added cauliflower pizza. It was really delicious and more like thin crust. Really good! Fries are also good.

ofunk-tree30
17.06.2023

This restaurant offers a distinctive and attractive setup: you can choose any available table outside, scan a QR code to view the menu, and place your order and make payments directly from your phone. The ambiance is enjoyable, and the food is quite tasty. However, it is a bit on the pricier side.

sunny-huel
17.06.2023

Great mood, burger was great, and the hard root beer is amazing! You would never know it contained alcohol!

monahan-kailyn
17.06.2023

Louis and Joni did it again! Not only a totally cool adult mood, but the Bourbon cocktail menu was perfect! Loved my bungalow with burger and Lanza Farm goat cheese. And the Veggie plate with fried pickles!!! Yeah, fun night. Thanks for your Peekskill love!

bwunsch-rabbit8029
17.06.2023

Great food and an amazing selection of Bourbon. The waitress was very friendly and recommended two great decisions. Portions are a drop small, so I would recommend doing the double part for a burger or just more of the delicious food. Look forward to going back soon!

Nestled in Peekskill, this brewery offers a unique dining experience marked by its unconventional atmosphere and self-service model. Diners order via QR codes, reminiscent of fast-food chains, and often face challenges in accessing staff for assistance. While the beer selection receives praise, the food sometimes disappoints, with reports of mediocre pizzas and sandwiches lacking authenticity. The lively ambiance, enhanced by loud music, may appeal to some but detracts from a relaxed dining experience. Despite mixed reviews, the brewery enjoys a prime location and a pet-friendly outdoor area, making it a popular spot for casual gatherings after a day of exploration.

Top-rated

Last update : 14.11.2023

4.2 ★ from 10 reviews
mari-d-4
14.11.2023

Great experience! Staff is incredibly attentive and super friendly. We felt like we were amongst friends. The beer is amazing and very tasty food!

kati-h-5
14.11.2023

Good beer, ok food, service was.. not great. The employees seemed more interested in their own conversations and phones rather than customers. The music was loud dance music, like what you’d hear in a night club except it was a brewery at lunch time. I did like the convenient location. Likelihood of returning 3/10

mike-f-3
14.11.2023

I only deliver from this place. As far as breweries go. This is one of the go to spots in Peekskill. ALWAYS has been. Direct access to the train LITERALLY across the street from it. A bevy selection of different light and dark drafts... ales, and etc. The food is pretty good. Kinda crowded seating inside since the brewing vats can be seen behind the bar when you come in... electronic scoring tournament darts here. Great seating outside though. And it's a haven to bring your pets to eat with you... its like a little pet bar outside. Don't ask me to explain it, I'm just telling you what I saw. Not my ideal sit down and eat spot... but a great place to chop it up with the fellas or the ladies after a hard days work over some brews.

5denzi-yishey-4-mont
14.11.2023

We went for lunch on a weekday and it was not crowded. The service was good and the beer was excellent. Pizza and wings both were upto our expectation and we loved them. The only improvement they need is in the French fries which was little over burnt. Loved the atmosphere too.

brooke-m-4
14.11.2023

An absolute MUST GO recommendation for anyone in the area! Food, drinks, and the best service from David behind the bar!! Can't wait to go back again soon! The poutine fries and chicken empanadas were delicious. Perfect portion with just the right amount of munchies to wash down with a fresh brew on tap. Tried both their sours and they blew my mind.

Sirved

Last update : 03.01.2024

3.5 ★ from 4 reviews
kenneth-coleman-2
03.01.2024

This place was truly amazing! After a three-hour hike in the area, my future brother-in-law and I decided to stop for some food and beer, and we couldn’t have been happier. The beer selection was impressive, and the food quality was top-notch. They also provide vegan options for anyone with dietary restrictions.

kenneth-coleman-offi
03.01.2024

The atmosphere was quite unique, but not in the best way. There were no servers or hosts, which made it challenging to find a table, creating a bit of chaos. Instead of traditional menus, they used QR codes for ordering through your phone, a practice that seems to have stuck around since the pandemic. It felt reminiscent of a McDonald's, but with beer. If you had a question about a beer or food item, good luck getting someone’s attention. I had to request silverware, and I wasn't even offered water. The pizza tasted like it was straight out of a microwave, and the Cuban sandwich was just basic deli meat—definitely no pickles to be found. While the beer was decent, it wasn't enough to make me want to come back. Overall, it was a disappointing experience.

kenneth-coleman-3
03.01.2024

The beer was enjoyable, but the food was merely average. Unfortunately, the service fell short; the staff appeared more interested in their own discussions and phones rather than in serving customers. The loud dance music created an atmosphere that felt more appropriate for a nightclub than a brewery at lunchtime. On the bright side, the location is quite convenient. Overall, I would rate my chances of returning as a 3 out of 10.

kenneth-coleman-beac
03.01.2024

Peekskill Brewery offers excellent beer, tasty pizza, and great music! I tried the Hazy IPA and a taco pizza, and both hit the spot perfectly. The sound system played Helmet's "Unsong," which took me back to my youth, along with other nostalgic tracks, making the experience even better. The menu features a variety of IPAs, sours, ales, and ciders. With both indoor and outdoor seating available in a quiet part of town, Peekskill Brewery is definitely the place to stop for a pint or three!

Menu

Last update : 05.04.2023

3.3 ★ from 3 reviews
shawn-johnston-mecha-1
05.04.2023

My husband and I recently stopped by Peekskill on our way back from a hiking trip, and we had a wonderful experience at this brewery! It's located just a short walk from the metro station, which makes it very convenient.

twisoky-farmer2140
05.04.2023

We visited this restaurant the day after their big annual block party, so some menu items were unfortunately unavailable. Nevertheless, it turned out to be a wonderful find on a chilly autumn afternoon with...

giovanni86-1
05.04.2023

I was thrilled to find this brewery in Peekskill, which was bustling on Saturday. We decided to order based on the recommendations, anticipating it would be great, unless...

Facebook
4.3 ★ from 394 reviews
Google
4.1 ★ from 663 reviews
Tripadvisor
2.9 ★ from 18 reviews
Yelp
3.5 ★ from 757 reviews
Menuwithprice
4.3 ★ from 154 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Peekskill