Carmen’s - Peekskill

Dominican, Chicken, Western
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Carmen’s

Carmen’s
4.3 / 5 (40 reviews)

Description

Nestled in Peekskill, this new Dominican restaurant offers a mixed bag of experiences. While many patrons rave about the delicious food—like the perfectly cooked oxtail and flavorful fried chicken—concerns around customer service and pricing persist. Some diners report loud music and burned rice, while others highlight the friendly staff and generous portions. Despite hiccups with deliveries and high prices, the overall consensus leans towards satisfaction with the cuisine. Regulars appreciate the much-needed Caribbean fare and hope for more offerings in the future, suggesting that while improvements are needed, the foundation for a promising dining experience is established.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: julissa

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 40 reviews
drowe-doctor3967
27.06.2022

I was thrilled to discover a Dominican restaurant offering authentic cuisine in our area. The food was absolutely delicious! The owner and staff were incredibly kind and friendly. I thoroughly enjoyed my experience and will definitely be returning!

kaley01
27.06.2022

Carmen's restaurant in Western Chester County is hands down the best place to enjoy delicious Dominican cuisine. The food is simply addicting, especially the cakes. Wishing Carmen nothing but success in the future.

ivanovic-bruno
27.06.2022

The food is delicious but RIDICULOUSLY OVERPRICED! You can see in the photo, they charged my cousin over $100 for the food in the picture and 2 soda’s. Easily $40-45 max anywhere else. When we called because so much was missing all we got was attitude. Horrible customer service. They lost SEVERAL CUSTOMERS TODAY!

julissa-roman-1
05.04.2024

This restaurant never picks up the phone when I call to make a reservation.

r-zel-2
05.04.2024

The restaurant was empty, but the music was so loud that we assumed it was open. The food was too salty for my liking, so we decided to give it a try. However, we probably won't be returning. It was good to give it a chance, but now we know the outcome.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.