Amici’s Pizza - Peekskill

I just started a new construction project nearby and decided to try the chicken parmesan and pepperoni pizza from this restaurant. Both dishes were fantastic! I... read more I just started a new construction project nearby and decided to try the chicken parmesan and pepperoni pizza from this restaurant. Both dishes were fantastic! I've been back several times since, and I don’t think I would want to eat anywhere else. I might end up gaining a few pounds, but honestly, I don’t mind because the food is so delicious! – Atrin H.

We visit this restaurant frequently. They offer a very thin crust pizza that we love, especially the Big Buff Chicken and BBQ Guy varieties, which are usually a... read more We visit this restaurant frequently. They offer a very thin crust pizza that we love, especially the Big Buff Chicken and BBQ Guy varieties, which are usually a perfect 10 out of 10. However, I must be honest—the last two times we came in, the pizza in the display case looked old. If it continues to look like this, I’ll have to lower my rating to a 3 and may not return. But if the quality returns to normal, I would be happy to give it a 5-star rating, as the pizza is truly worth it.

This restaurant has recently come under new ownership, and as loyal customers of Amicis for the past 12 years, we can confidently say it's better than ever. The... read more This restaurant has recently come under new ownership, and as loyal customers of Amicis for the past 12 years, we can confidently say it's better than ever. The new owners have truly transformed the place, and the food is absolutely delicious, complemented by excellent service. I highly recommend Amicis—your pizza is among the best we've ever had, and the prices are very reasonable too.

This restaurant has recently come under new ownership, and we've been regular customers of Amicis for the past 12 years. It was always quite good, but the new o... read more This restaurant has recently come under new ownership, and we've been regular customers of Amicis for the past 12 years. It was always quite good, but the new owners have truly elevated the experience—the food is absolutely delicious, and the service is excellent. I highly recommend Amicis. Their pizza is among the best in the area, and the prices are very reasonable as well.

Been coming here regularly for a while. They have great thin crust pizza if you like that. Big buff chicken and BBQ guy and 99% of the time they are 10 out of 1... read more Been coming here regularly for a while. They have great thin crust pizza if you like that. Big buff chicken and BBQ guy and 99% of the time they are 10 out of 10. But I have to be honest, last 2 times I've been in there the pizza in the window has looked old. If it looks that way next time this will go down to 3 and I won't be back. If it's back to normal I'll happily bump this up to a 5 star rating the pizza is worth it.