Hellriegel's Inn - Painesville

Catering, Steakhouse, Casual
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +14403549530

Menu

The menu of Hellriegel's Inn from Painesville includes 109 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $19.9. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Nestled on the east side of Cleveland, this nostalgic restaurant promises a unique dining experience, noted for its impressive Prime Rib and Filet, alongside delightful Ranch potatoes. While some patrons enjoy the warm atmosphere and attentive service, others express disappointment in food quality and service inconsistencies during busy events like Thanksgiving and holiday buffets. While prices may lean towards the higher end, many guests appreciate the generous portions and classic offerings. However, some recent diners find the food lacking in flavor and warmth. Despite mixed reviews, the charm of the venue and its long-standing reputation draw both new and returning visitors.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Thomas

Images

Hellriegel's Inn Food Hellriegel's Inn Food Hellriegel's Inn Food Hellriegel's Inn Food Hellriegel's Inn Drink Hellriegel's Inn Food Hellriegel's Inn Food Hellriegel's Inn Food

Feedback

★ 3.3 / 5 from 933 reviews

Was Thomas McCartan at Hellriegel's Inn a mag?
Even after 75 years in business, this restaurant still delivers great food. I had Thanksgiving dinner there last night and was impressed by the flavors and taste. The only downside was that the food could have been a bit warmer. I've heard their Sunday brunch is amazing, so I definitely want to try it out. Kristina in reservations was fantastic and was able to accommodate more of us on the day before the holiday. View all feedback.

What Kevin Kelley dislikes about Hellriegel's Inn:
I attended this restaurant's Thanksgiving buffet and found the experience lacking. The service was subpar, and our server appeared overwhelmed; we often had to look for her to get things like drink refills or rolls. Additionally, our table was missing butter for the rolls. The turkey was a bit tough—not dry, but definitely chewy. Surprisingly, even the mashed potatoes seemed to be a struggle for the kitchen, despite... View all feedback.

braxton82
Braxton 17.06.2023 - 06:51

The service at this restaurant was excellent. I have a shellfish allergy and the server was very attentive, checking with the kitchen staff to ensure my perch dinner could be prepared safely. The dish was pan-seared to perfection and delicious. Thank you!

ugerlach-fish57
Jermain 17.06.2023 - 06:51

We had a nice Thanksgiving dinner. Very basic buffet for the $29.00 price per person, would like to see more items. The staff was very nice and friendly.

ar-bathtub-refinishi
Ar 24.01.2024 - 20:00

Awful experience. I rarely write restaurant reviews, but the Thanksgiving buffet at Hellriegel's Inn was a huge letdown. We definitely won't be coming back!

thomas-mccartan
Thomas 24.01.2024 - 20:00

After 75 years in operation, Hellriegel's Inn continues to serve excellent food. I enjoyed Thanksgiving dinner there last night and was impressed by the rich flavors and taste. The only minor drawback was that the food could have been served a little warmer. I've heard their Sunday brunch is outstanding, so I’m eager to try it soon. Kristina in reservations was wonderful and managed to accommodate our larger group just a day before the holiday.

ben-becker-3
Ben 24.01.2024 - 20:00

This place feels nostalgic, and I absolutely love it. Instead of trying to describe the atmosphere, I suggest you just visit one evening. I hadn’t eaten here before, but the servers were fantastic and the bar had a delightful charm. UPDATE: I’ve now had the chance to dine here. We were a group of five on the outdoor patio. We enjoyed cocktails and dinner, and our server was exceptional. The cocktails were amazing, and each of us truly relished our meals. I must say, the presence of my 21-year-old daughter and her boyfriend probably brought down the average age of the clientele by a good decade, but they enjoyed themselves as well.

  • Perch &Amp;Amp; Cod Ala Carte (Specialties)

    Perch Ala Carte
    Perch Ala Carte
    $54.9
  • Entrées

    Grape Juice Shrub
    Grape Juice Shrub
    $3.7
    Relish Dish (For Four)
    Relish Dish (For Four)
    $4.9
  • From The Garden

    Dinner Salad (Fresh Cut)
    Dinner Salad (Fresh Cut)
    $4.9
  • Dinner Entrées

    Dinner Entrees Full Course
    Dinner Entrees Full Course
    $29.9
    Dinner Entrees Ala Carte
    Dinner Entrees Ala Carte
    $23.9

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.