Gartman Model Bakery - Painesville

#37 - Asiatic - Painesville, #38 - Seafood - Painesville, Bakeries
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Gartman Model Bakery

Gartman Model Bakery
4.6 / 5 (521 reviews)

Description

Gartman Bakery stands out as a cherished, family-owned establishment renowned for its outstanding selection of baked goods. From delicious rhubarb pies to beautifully crafted wedding cakes, every item boasts remarkable quality and taste. Patrons appreciate the personal and professional service, as well as the affordability, with day-old pastries available at just $1. The bakery's loyal clientele often travels considerable distances to indulge in their favorite treats, including an array of donuts, cookies, and cakes. With a reputation built over decades, Gartman Bakery continues to be a treasured destination for sweet delights and memorable celebrations.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: 4Pops

Feedback

★ 4.6 / 5 from 521 reviews
pops-f
16.11.2023

Everything is good here. Yes, even the large bags of day old pastries for $1.00. Good donuts. The variety of donuts is good as well. I have had a few of their other pastries, and there is definitely nothing to complain about. The service has always been good when I went. I THINK they only take cash, so call ahead or take cash.

judy-w-5
16.11.2023

This is a fantastic family-owned bakery that has been serving the community for many years! Everything they create is top-notch. I've been a loyal customer for quite some time, and in my opinion, their cakes, pies, and donuts are the best in the area.

clint-c-5
16.11.2023

Really miss this place since moving out of the area. Bought a delicious rhubarb pie after being presented with a vast array of strudels, pies, pastries, cookies etc.

stephanie-c-17
16.11.2023

I had my wedding cake made here in April, and it turned out beautiful—exactly as we envisioned! I would definitely recommend this place. Everything else on offer is wonderful too.

sarah-e-4
16.11.2023

Gartman's Bakery always has a delectable selection of donuts, cakes, cookies, and pies. They have wonderful costumers service as well. You can call ahead your order and it will be ready on time for you to pick it up. I would suggest getting there early (before 1pm) as they sell out quickly of the days offerings.

FAQ

The restaurant offers free WLAN for its guests.

More information

QR-Code for the menu

QR code for the menu of Gartman Model Bakery

Suggested nearby restaurants.