Reviews
What Samantha Bailey likes about The Old Library Restaurant & Inn:
Love the atmosphere and the preservation of history. The food and cocktails are excellent! This gem is certainly worth it for your next lunch or dinner out! An easy drive from Ellicottville and surrounding ski towns as well!Vegetarian options: Wide variety of vegetarian options! View all feedback. What Daniel Orzelek doesn't like about The Old Library Restaurant & Inn:
I was reminded of this place as I thought about interesting Calgary restaurants I have been to and I realized I probably forgot to leave a review but about a year ago on Christmas week I came here for one of their special courses and the food was ok but when I went to pay they forced me to tip like 40$ approximately and said it was like policy or something but none of this information was made known beforehand and ho... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Andrew Carnegie designed this modest library converted into a trendy restaurant, so good views, nice tap beers but the Yuengling was a bit skunky. Bar maid offe...
read moreThis is a great place to visit. Definitely stepping back in time. Good beer selection.
When I was young, The Old Library was a restaurant staple in Olean! That's why I was so happy to see it reopened as a full-time restaurant, and not just an even...
read moreAfter the response from the owner for my previous review, I figured I'd edit this completely. I appreciate the response. The food was excellent, though I still...
read moreVery disappointed in the quality of food and additions for the cost. Definitely would not order food again from here unless the quality greatly increased or the...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe Old Library Restaurant in Olean, New York, offers a unique dining experience in a historic Carnegie library setting. While some diners appreciated the preservation of history and variety of vegetarian options, others were not impressed with the food quality and pricing. Some customers were disappointed in the lack of communication regarding menu changes and tipping policies, while others praised the attentive service and well-made cocktails. Overall, The Old Library Restaurant is recommended for its atmosphere, wide range of menu options, and exceptional service for special occasions.
Haven't been in a few years but LOVE the desserts! Great service..best place to eat in Olean.
I had my wedding and reception here and everything seemed wonderful at firstGreat price, came with a wedding coordinator, and a beautiful room.
When I was growing up, The Old Library was reserved for special occasions like birthdays, anniversaries and graduations.
Looked at the menu last week, saw that Pasta Louis was still available on their menu. I wanted to go home. The man who answered the phone said it was not availa...
read moreMenu tries to be extreme 5 stars and measures many miles. if they have any food problems, they don't eat here. menu has too chic descriptions that they do not l...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI tried out The Old Library Restaurant today and I found it really lovely. The building is so lovely and it was fun to experience that old architecture. We...
This restaurant was absolutely divine in the decoration and the ambiance. The waiter gave us the choice of which dining area to sit in, and the books and...
Years and years ago, I had stopped here several times while passing through the area. I had very fond memories of those visits, so I decided to stop again...
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more