Renna's Pizza - Olean

Every time I'm in Olean, I stop by the mall and go to rennas pizzeria. I love the pizza, and for $7 you can get two pepperoni slices and a small pepsi. This is... read more Every time I'm in Olean, I stop by the mall and go to rennas pizzeria. I love the pizza, and for $7 you can get two pepperoni slices and a small pepsi. This is cheaper today than McDonald's food. I recommend Renna for your quick afternoon stop or for your dinner. Not only do they have other things to eat next to pizza, the staff is also very polite..

At last, it feels like the incredible flavor of Renna's pizza from my childhood has returned. I'm not sure what changed, but there was a time when it just wasn'... read more At last, it feels like the incredible flavor of Renna's pizza from my childhood has returned. I'm not sure what changed, but there was a time when it just wasn't good. However, it's once again AMAZING!

The pizza was fantastic! I was a bit disappointed that they didn't have any anchovies, so I opted for mushrooms and black olives instead. Nonetheless, it was st... read more The pizza was fantastic! I was a bit disappointed that they didn't have any anchovies, so I opted for mushrooms and black olives instead. Nonetheless, it was still a great pizza!

I've been enjoying this pizza since the 1970s, and every bite still tastes just as amazing as the very first time! If you're a fan of thin crust, this is defini... read more I've been enjoying this pizza since the 1970s, and every bite still tastes just as amazing as the very first time! If you're a fan of thin crust, this is definitely the best spot. It's been locally operated for years, and their crust is expertly made. Another favorite of mine is the fresh orange line they offer—simply delicious! If you haven't tried Renna yet, you definitely should!

The restaurant has really declined. The charm it once had seems to be gone. They've started using these strange screens under the pizza for some reason, which g... read more The restaurant has really declined. The charm it once had seems to be gone. They've started using these strange screens under the pizza for some reason, which gives it a different texture. What used to be a nicely crispy crust is no longer the case. Ten years ago, this place was the best, but now it's just mediocre. It's quite disappointing.