Mickey's - Olean

#17 - Pizza - Olean, #38 - Seafood - Olean, Steak
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +17163723467

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Mickey's from Olean featuring all 39 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Thomas

Images

Mickey's Food Mickey's Food Mickey's Food Mickey's Food Mickey's Menu Mickey's Menu Mickey's Food Mickey's Menu

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 619 reviews

Was Jennifer W at Mickey's a mag?
I visited this restaurant on a whim one Friday afternoon. Although I am new to the area, my fiancé is acquainted with the owner. I learned that the restaurant has been passed down to the owner's son. I had a wonderful time chatting with both of them. As someone who has experienced a similar situation, I found it heartwarming to see their legacy continuing. I highly recommend trying the stuffed peppers appetizer and t... View all feedback.

What Paul T dislikes about Mickey's:
The food at this restaurant was terrible. We waited almost 45 minutes before anyone even acknowledged us, and when we finally spoke up, we were told to be patient. Despite the poor service, we tried to enjoy the food, but when it arrived nearly half an hour later, it looked nothing like what was advertised. To make matters worse, my wife noticed what appeared to be rat droppings in her dish. When we brought this to t... View all feedback.

lindgren-dallas
Dallas 30.03.2023 - 11:19

The seafood is the best in olean. my wife had a steak and it was perfect. mickey’s is #1 in the city

lindgren-dallas
Dallas 30.04.2023 - 06:39

The best Philly steak sub I have ever had since Tom in Ellicotville owned the Hougie Haus.

jennifer-w-cat7553
Jennifer 15.04.2024 - 03:25

I visited this restaurant on a whim one Friday afternoon. Although I am new to the area, my fiancé is acquainted with the owner. I learned that the restaurant has been passed down to the owner's son. I had a wonderful time chatting with both of them. As someone who has experienced a similar situation, I found it heartwarming to see their legacy continuing. I highly recommend trying the stuffed peppers appetizer and the fish sandwich.

thomas-weitzel-grass
Thomas 26.08.2024 - 05:17

Whenever I am in Olean, I always make sure to visit Mickey's and B&B.

crystal-gold
Crystal 26.08.2024 - 05:17

We LOVE Mickeys so much ! I love the penne a la Mickey and the Pizza.. and the steak sub is delish also but I dont get that too much my son loves the pizza and spaghetti he is 10 and we were just in Tennessee for 2 weeks and dropped 2 pant sizes the food SUCKED and all we could dream about was our beloved MIckeys and getting home and its Sunday and they are closed until Tuesday !!! nooooooo. lol

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.