Popsy's Pizzeria - Old Forge

Ordered fries, fried pickles, and a Large stuffed crust extra cheese Supreme pizza. Came home it was all but Supreme. Tim personally delivered to me what I originally ordered, free of charge. Pizza was Very Good and the fried pickles were NICE sized appetizers. I will be back, highly recommended. Updated: 5-21-22 Ordered $70 worth of food. Always good. Can't complain. Make sure they verify your order. Didn't get my jalapeno poppers, called before closing, they ignored the call 5 times. This is the 2nd time my order is wrong, so I changed my review from 5 stars to 3. The food is good, service seems inept. I ordered a extra meat cheese steak and I couldn't tell the difference between my wife's normal cheese steak and my extra meat. Disappointed tonight.

Sry orders pizza a while back and it was good ...today on the other hand got a cheeseburger with lettuce and tomatoe...well it took over an hr to get here from 5 minutes away they forgot my salad and fries were soggy and wilted lettuce..now I know we all have bad days I worked in the business for 20 years...trust me I understand can't serve food like this fellas....

Had the pleasure of ordering some Honey barbecue wings and the wife got the garlic parmesan wings.. Both were pretty amazing, although we messed up by ordering just a few slices, shouldve gotten the whole pie lol.. Go check em out good environment and Great Food

Ordered two round pizza's one plain and one with pepperoni. Both were excellent I'm glad we ordered there. Good luck guy's I'll be back

Pizza was fantastic, best round in the area! Can't wait to try the fried Sicilian!Thank you!