Castaway Grill - Ocean Beach

Often go here for wing night on Mondays, but the rest of their menu is excellent reasonably priced as well. Recently had them cater a birthday party for nine adults. It was perfect. Can’t get any better on Fire Island!

We saw some negative reviews and were a bit nervous that it would be a letdown. We were pleasantly surprised! It was a rainy day, so many other restaurants had closed kitchens closed but not Castaway! Natalia, our server, was very laid back and friendly with us. Our food came out SO fast. The steak sandwich was incredible, and the shrimp tacos (though spicy) were delectable. Would recommend.

Castaway is a great restaurant. They had a loud but not bad band playing live music, good vibe, good drinks, and the food was good. However if you go for dinner beware. The food is good but the chef LOVES pepper. I’ve been here twice, ordered a chicken pasta in 2021 and mahi mahi sandwich in 2022 (the menu changes so that’s a fun surprise and both times the food was peppered to all hell. Chef thinks you can only blacken/char the food if you cover every inch with black pepper. The food was still good but please do a little less with the black pepper chef . Much love

Castaway fried rice, as a worker on the island you can get a little lonely sometimes. But when I'm lonely you know what's there for me? Castaway fried rice. When I was sad and didn't think I was worth a dime? Castaway fried rice, what comforts me before I go to sleep at night? You know it. Castaway fried rice. Service: Take out Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Chicken sandwich was absolutely delicious, great restaurant Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5