The Mudhole - Nutley

I've always had a great dining experience here. The menu is extensive, and I've never been disappointed with my choices. The atmosphere is very rustic, making i... read more I've always had a great dining experience here. The menu is extensive, and I've never been disappointed with my choices. The atmosphere is very rustic, making it a fantastic spot to enjoy a burger and a beer.

The ribs I tried were incredibly tender, almost as if they had been smoked for hours; they effortlessly fell off the bone and melted in my mouth. Jim should def... read more The ribs I tried were incredibly tender, almost as if they had been smoked for hours; they effortlessly fell off the bone and melted in my mouth. Jim should definitely consider opening a new location in Tennessee just for his ribs!

If there’s one place I can confidently critique, it's Jim D's! I've eaten there over 100 times since moving to Nutley, and it’s so convenient... read more If there’s one place I can confidently critique, it's Jim D's! I've eaten there over 100 times since moving to Nutley, and it’s so convenient...