Nutley Diner

Food was ok at best. Home fries was not cooked or browned enough, I could still taste the raw potato. Waffle was not crispy or not even browned. Very hard to fl... read more Food was ok at best. Home fries was not cooked or browned enough, I could still taste the raw potato. Waffle was not crispy or not even browned. Very hard to flag someone down for a coffee refill. With all that, it's not cheap!

I had a fantastic experience at this diner! Our waitress, Carrol, was friendly and attentive from the moment we arrived until we departed. The food was fresh, h... read more I had a fantastic experience at this diner! Our waitress, Carrol, was friendly and attentive from the moment we arrived until we departed. The food was fresh, hot, and served in a timely manner. I highly recommend this spot for brunch or a quick bite. The cream of broccoli soup was delightful, my chicken fettuccine Alfredo was excellent, and my girlfriend loved her cheesesteak without any toppings. I just wish I could have tipped Carrol more!

The waiter was extremely friendly and attentive, even making an effort to accommodate a substitution request. Additionally, the restroom was clean. read more The waiter was extremely friendly and attentive, even making an effort to accommodate a substitution request. Additionally, the restroom was clean.

We had dinner for two and enjoyed a wonderful meal. I ordered a chicken, bacon, Swiss cheese, and avocado sandwich served with fries, while my companion chose t... read more We had dinner for two and enjoyed a wonderful meal. I ordered a chicken, bacon, Swiss cheese, and avocado sandwich served with fries, while my companion chose the three-slider cheeseburger and disco fries as appetizers. I had a Diet Pepsi from the fountain to drink. Everything was delicious, and the staff created a great atmosphere. There was decent parking available, with some free spots and others that required payment. We didn't use the restrooms during our visit. Overall, it was a really good dining experience.

My breakfast bowl was incredible! The steak was perfectly seasoned and cooked, the home fries were spot on, and the eggs and veggies were fresh and bursting wit... read more My breakfast bowl was incredible! The steak was perfectly seasoned and cooked, the home fries were spot on, and the eggs and veggies were fresh and bursting with flavor! It was hands down the best breakfast I've had in a long time. The sautéed asparagus was simply delightful and made for a perfect addition to my meal. My guest also remarked that their breakfast was excellent. With fantastic food and outstanding customer service, everything was superb! I will definitely be returning to Nutley Diner for breakfast again!