Subway - Newburgh

#16 - Fast Food - Newburgh, Vegetarian Friendly, Breakfast
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Subway

Subway
3.7 / 5 (600 reviews)

Description

A neighborhood sandwich outlet earns mixed reviews: praised for convenient online ordering, dependable pickup and an enjoyable caramel-apple cookie, but criticized for inconsistent portion sizes, occasional stale ingredients and order errors. Some customers report unprofessional drive‑thru interactions and limited visibility into sandwich preparation, leading to surprises at home. Expect fast-casual service with a drive‑thru focus—good for quick mobile orders, but watch for variability in freshness and value.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lynn

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 600 reviews
lynn
02.07.2024

Didn't get all the toppings I wanted on my foot long subway melt, and the lettuce was bad.

david-hillman-2
02.07.2024

Both of their bathrooms had out of order stickers on them I don't know if that's true or not but you need to be able to wash your hands before you can eat, and you shouldn't eat here.

bill-chatmon-1
02.07.2024

I like Subway but this might be the worst in the area. Hours open seem to change here without notice. The staff does not seem happy to see you arrive. The most unwelcoming Subway I have been too.Parking: The drive through is horrible. Almost a blind exit behind a Gas Station.

terra-wintner
02.07.2024

I would truly give this place zero stars if I could. What they serve is completely inedible. This is supposed to be a foot-long meatball, but it's far from it. The other two foot-long sandwiches we ordered were just as disappointing. Save your money and avoid this restaurant.

amber-bohn
02.07.2024

I ordered the cold cut trio footlong on flatbread, and I have to say, I was extremely disappointed. There was only one thin layer of meat – maybe five slices total, spread out along the length of the sandwich. I had to open it just to find the meat! To make matters worse, it didn’t have the cucumbers or banana peppers that I requested, and the flatbread wasn't even toasted. I’ve never felt so frustrated about wasting my money. If there were a way to give negative stars, I would absolutely do it. I strongly advise against supporting this establishment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.