Stellas Pizzería - Newburgh

So the chicken marsala was kinda lacking but it was still very good the pasta wasn't over cooked (LOVED that) your garlic knots are so amazing they are so soft. the mozzarella sticks were great also. your marinara sauce is really good also

Eggplant Parmigiana amazing good portions great sauce

This is the best pizza I’ve had since I left Brooklyn. Keep up the great work! You’ve become my go-to spot for pizza. Always a top-notch experience!

The dough was too thin to taste, and the ricotta was overly runny.

The Cheese Pie alone deserves five stars—it was absolutely delicious and the large size is impressive! This has quickly become our favorite pizza spot. However, we decided to try a few other dishes and were let down. The Fried Calamari was tough and lacking in flavor. The Chicken Parmigiana dinner offered good value for the price, but the chicken pieces were dry. The meal included a side of spaghetti, a small salad with tomato, black olives, and slivers of onion, along with three garlic knots that were delicious. I had requested the marinara sauce on the side, and they got that right.