Casey's - Newburgh
Casey's
Menu
A complete overview of all 4 courses and drinks can be found here on the menu of Casey's from Newburgh.
Casey's in Newburgh, IN, is a popular American restaurant known for its inviting atmosphere and diverse menu, earning an average rating of 3.7 stars. Operating hours this week are from 5:00 AM to 11:59 PM, so don’t miss your chance to enjoy a meal—call ahead and reserve your table at (812) 858-2697. With a variety of options, including vegetarian dishes, there’s something to satisfy every palate. If you're looking for similar dining experiences, consider trying Azzip Pizza or Fiesta Acapulco Mexican Restaurant. Enjoyed your visit? We’d love to hear your thoughts—leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
Was Jonathan Fox at Casey's a mag?
The staff at this restaurant are welcoming, and the service is top-notch. However, there's one drawback for those of us who work night shifts: many gas stations that cater to flex fuel vehicles tend to be closed late at night. I almost ran out of gas while trying to find one that was open, and every place I visited was closed. View all feedback.
What Arturo Hintz dislikes about Casey's:
It's important to mention that this is just a pizza restaurant, so there's no need for such strict policies. My experience was frustrating and made me rethink the rationale behind their practices. I commend the builders for creating a nice space, but the staff could certainly use some training. View all feedback.
The people are nice and friendly and the service is great. The only bad thing about this place is for the people who work at night they cut those of us with flex fuel vehicles off I almost ran out of gas trying to find an open station and everylocation I went too the dispenser is closed
As soon as you walk in, the staff welcomes you with warmth. The food is both fresh and tasty. I had the cookie and gravy pizza, and it absolutely amazed me! If you skip this restaurant, you’re really missing out. I believe it deserves a full 10 stars!
The staff at this restaurant are welcoming, and the service is top-notch. However, there's one drawback for those of us who work night shifts: many gas stations that cater to flex fuel vehicles tend to be closed late at night. I almost ran out of gas while trying to find one that was open, and every place I visited was closed.
The staff welcomes you as soon as you enter the restaurant. The food is fresh and absolutely delicious. They introduced me to the biscuit and gravy pizza, and it was incredible! If you haven't visited the Bell Road location yet, you're really missing out. I would give it a 10-star rating!
It's important to mention that this is just a pizza restaurant, so there's no need for such strict policies. My experience was frustrating and made me rethink the rationale behind their practices. I commend the builders for creating a nice space, but the staff could certainly use some training.
Menu
More information
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.4 / 5 (335 reviews)#9 Fast Food in Newburgh SandwichesSubway
W High Pointe Dr 8426, 47630 Newburgh, US
"THIS GREEDY FRANCHISE OWNER DOESNT HONOR ANY OF THE SUBWAY"
★ 3.4 / 5 (1437 reviews)#10 Mexican in NewburghTaco Bell
W State Route 66 8099, 47630 Newburgh, US
"The inconsistency of the dining room being open one day and closed the next is frustrating. When I raised my concern, the manager explained that they..."
★ 4.4 / 5 (5588 reviews)#6 Seafood in Newburgh American FoodThe Tin Fish
707 State St, Newburgh, IN 47630, USA, United States
"This restaurant is far from a 5 stars."