Reviews
What Massimo likes about Sal And Carmine Pizza:
this. is. the best. slice. in nyc. pepperoni is definitely better than bleeker streets and all those that live in this hood are so lucky its a local joint for them. the crust has the perfect balance of greasy and gooey top with a nice flop on the crust without losing crispiness. its just a solid slice of heaven View all feedback. What berroberry doesn't like about Sal And Carmine Pizza:
I've always loved this place and thought it was the best in the neighborhood but they have been inconsistent. I ordered a few slices through Amazon Prime Now and they tasted like someone forgot to add the full amount of sauce. Too bad because it was a neighborhood standby. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Not sure how the rating isn 't higher, maybe cause I 'm just a country boy from down South and we sureeee ain 't got pizza like this below the Mason-Dixon. It '...
read moreThough I wanted to eat here with my friends, the gentleman making pizzas told us he did not have time to make a pizza. He also said we couldn’t eat some of the...
read moreI have had their pie a few times, it's darn near addictive. It amazes me how something so familiar and so simple can be so varied in style and flavor. I have ha...
read moreWe ordered take out. It arrived hot and the pizza was fantastic. We had pepperoni. This is a must do pizza place on the upper west side!
This place was very close to our hotel, and we wanted an afternoon snack after a few beers so ventured into this little place. There was pre made pizzas to heat...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreLuch makes the best pizza in the city... family owned shop for 65 years. Doesn't get more New York than that
Easily a top 5 pizza place in NYC. I just moved to the neighborhood and I eat there most times twice a week.
The best pizza in the city. An upper west side institution.
I come back to New York JUST for this pizza!!!!! Hands down best ever!
My husband and I went here in 2016. I stupidly thought I would remember the place name to recommend to friends. I forgot (in my defense we tried a lot of pizza...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreBest pizza anywhere and I've been to many different states. I've been eating there since the early 70s when they were on 95th.
Excellent NY pizza. Exactly what you need.
Ho vissuto per 1 mese a New York e dormivo in un appartamento sopra questa pizzeria, ci andavo sempre e me li porterò sempre nel cuore, personale gentilissimo e...
read moreWhat God intended when he invented cheese slice
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more