New York Pizza - New Orleans

Casual, Pizza, Bronx Next Door
4418 Magazine St, 70115, New Orleans, US, United States
Dishes: 34
New York Pizza menu
Full menu with prices & pictures
Address
New York Pizza 4418 Magazine St, 70115, New Orleans...
New York Pizza phone
+15048912376
Table Reservation
Reserve a table now for New York Pizza

Menu

The menu of New York Pizza from New Orleans comprises about 34 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $16.5 for a dish / drink.

New York Pizza offers a lively atmosphere and a promising menu, but diners find their experiences vary significantly. While some guests appreciate the relaxed vibe and friendly service, others express disappointment, especially regarding the pizza quality and service speed. The "Pint and Slice" deal garners praise for its affordability and late-night availability. However, critiques include underwhelming pizza flavors and inconsistencies in menu items. Despite the mixed reviews, many agree that if you're seeking a true New York-style pizza, you might want to explore other options. Still, the potential for a great experience remains for adventurous diners.

Last update: 14.03.2025

Images

New York Pizza food New York Pizza food New York Pizza food New York Pizza food New York Pizza inside New York Pizza food New York Pizza food New York Pizza food New York Pizza food New York Pizza food

Reserve now

Reserve a table

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 1375 reviews

Was User at New York Pizza a mag?
This restaurant offers a hearty eating experience in a lively atmosphere. Their "Pint and Slice" deal for just $6 is unbeatable, especially since they're one of the few places open at midnight where you can enjoy a good meal! View all feedback.

What User dislikes about New York Pizza:
The food was good, and the staff was friendly, but I'm giving fewer stars because management needs to ensure that the staff is properly trained. The host/cashier mistakenly informed me that federally issued forms of ID are not valid for purchasing alcohol. View all feedback.

cheryl-457
Cheryl 28.07.2023 - 21:35

This is a fantastic restaurant with delicious food. We decided to stop by on a whim after being drawn in by the enticing smell of the pizza. We ordered the meat pizza and a muffuletta, and both were excellent. The bartender, Malichian, was wonderful—friendly and attentive, which made for a relaxing and enjoyable experience. I highly recommend this place!

ebony-47
Ebony 28.07.2023 - 21:35

Oh my goodness, you guys! I just had to share my experience! We visited this place to use a restaurant.com certificate, and I’m so glad we did! The food was absolutely amazing! First of all, Eric delivered excellent customer service, even though he got super busy after we arrived. And let me tell you about the salad...

laniya-1
Laniya 28.07.2023 - 21:35

The pizza here is excellent! We ordered the extra-large (16") Big Apple. While the crust in the center was a bit soggy, the outer edges were fantastic. Being located on Magazine Street, parking can be a challenge, and you should expect to pay around $36 for a pizza. Also, be ready to wait, as this isn't fast food. Overall, I plan to return—it's a great spot with a cool vibe and friendly people.

louis-m-teacher841
Louis 01.11.2023 - 11:54

It was really fantastic! I just enjoyed a 14-inch pepperoni pizza. It had a thin, crispy crust and was slightly greasy (in a good way)—totally reminiscent of New York-style pizza. The Caesar salad was also delicious! I'm definitely planning to return!

joseph-a-fern24
joseph 01.11.2023 - 11:54

The BBQ pizza should resemble pulled pork or shredded chicken in a sauce, rather than just pieces of chicken scattered on a pizza. It doesn't resemble the picture at all. I ended up with a chicken pizza.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.